Strange New Worlds: Looking Ahead to Season 5

A Star Trek-themed spoiler warning.

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4, and minor spoilers for Season 5. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: The Original Series, The Animated Series, and Discovery Season 2.

So Season 4 has come to an end – the final ten-episode season of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. There’ll be a measly six episodes next year (well, I assume it’ll be next year), because apparently those extra four episodes were really just fucking up Paramount’s budget. I sound disappointed by that… but after Season 4 brought more misses than hits to the table, and went *all-in* on some pretty poor genre spoofs and parodies – at least one of which feels genuinely bad-natured the longer I’ve sat with it – maybe the truncated, shortened season will be a blessing.

Ahead of Season 5 – and before we’ve seen anything by way of trailers, teasers, or marketing material – I wanted to get my thoughts in order. Where does Strange New Worlds find itself ahead of its final few episodes? What might Season 5 potentially look like? What do I want it to look like – and, just as importantly, what do I want it *not* to look like? Is the series badly-damaged after episodes like Level-Five Writing Accident with its “but it was all just a dream” ending? And more fundamentally… is Strange New Worlds still the series that I’d call “the high-water mark of modern Star Trek” after all’s said and done?

Those questions and more are what we’re going to get into today.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing the shuttle set
Behind-the-scenes with the shuttlecraft set.

I say this a lot, especially in pieces like this, but it bears repeating: everything we’re going to discuss is the *subjective, not objective* opinion of just one old Trekkie. If you hate my take on Strange New Worlds, think I’ve completely got things wrong or misunderstood something, if I praise episodes and storylines you despise or shit all over ones you enjoyed, or if our views on Star Trek’s latest outing just don’t align… that should be okay! It’s also worth keeping in mind that I have no “insider information.” I’m not claiming that I know for a fact what Season 5 will look like or what kinds of stories it will tell – these are my preliminary thoughts and some speculation, and that’s all.

There ought to be room enough in the Star Trek fan community for differences of opinion and respectful disagreement that don’t descend into name-calling and general toxicity, and I share my thoughts on Strange New Worlds with the internet in that spirit. However, if you aren’t in the right headspace for opinions on this wonderful sci-fi franchise that you might not agree with… no hard feelings. Consider this a final “content warning” before we get into the potentially controversial stuff!

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Mount and Romijn being filmed
Rebecca Romijn and Anson Mount during the filming of Once La’an A Time.

Okay, with all of that out of the way… let’s take stock of where Strange New Worlds finds itself.

There were probably four episodes out of ten in Season 4 that I could put my hand on my heart and say I thought were either “good” or “great.” The rest… well, as disappointing as this is to say… they kinda sucked. And the part of that that has me genuinely anxious for Season 5 is that several of them doubled-down on the exact same mistakes – mistakes, in some cases, that the series has made before.

Because Seasons 4 and 5 went into production back-to-back – and before Season 3 had even finished airing – there wasn’t time to take on board feedback; to gauge what worked well and what didn’t after Season 2. With Season 4 having so many issues in multiple episodes… I’m deeply concerned that Season 5 is gonna repeat those problems. And with fewer episodes next time, there isn’t room for even a *single* bad one.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Wesley and Peck on set
Paul Wesley and Ethan Peck during production on the Season 4 finale.

Maybe Strange New Worlds’ writers got all of the dog shit ideas out of their system in Season 4, and Season 5 is gonna be stronger and more tightly-curated. I felt, at times, as if Season 4 was kind of a “let’s throw everything at the wall” batch of episodes; the writers and producers may genuinely have wanted to get all of these “creative” ideas made before the show came to an end. And it’s possible, I believe, that Season 5 might be more of a Discovery/Picard-inspired serialised story rather than a collection of episodic adventures. And if that’s the case… well, it’d better be a good story, right? But that could explain why so many of the episodes this season were these headfirst dives into parodies and spoofs, and why so many episodes seemed to pair up stories that didn’t really work well together; the writers and producers were getting all of their ideas out of the way before locking in for one final push to the finish line.

I don’t really want Season 5 to be serialised – though I’m about 99% certain that the finale, at least, will be a two-parter! But given how many weak episode ideas the team seem to have had this year… maybe a serialised story, if it’s a strong one, would be better. It might be an “emergency brake,” shutting down some of the writers’ stupidest ideas before they even get to the concept stage.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Anson Mount and director Sharon Lewis
Anson Mount being directed by Sharon Lewis for Orders of Magnitude.

Even though Season 4 only wrapped up a short while ago, the longer I’ve sat with it and had time to process these ten episodes, the more convinced I am that it’s done a lot of harm to Strange New Worlds’ overall reputation. Is the series still the “high-water mark of modern Star Trek,” as I’ve repeatedly claimed? Probably… but now that claim comes with an asterisk, and it almost feels like Strange New Worlds is only at the peak by default. Discovery was worse overall, basically a full one-third of Picard is unwatchable garbage, Starfleet Academy was a teen drama with some Star Trek haphazardly stuck to it, and Section 31 was a B-movie. So if you want live-action Star Trek in the 2020s, Strange New Worlds basically wins by default.

But that caveat is a big and growing one, and I would genuinely rank both Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass and Level-Five Writing Accident (as I’ve taken to calling it) as among the absolute worst stories that the franchise has told in this modern era. They’re right down in the sewer with Picard’s second season and some of Discovery’s godawful melodrama and failed “mental health” storylines. They truly were *that* bad.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S5 showing equipment backstage
A glimpse backstage during production on the upcoming fifth and final season.

Something you may have noticed, if you followed my reviews this year, is that I did something I very, very rarely do and genuinely do not enjoy doing: I called out an individual writer by name. Strange New Worlds’ Dana Horgan is responsible for writing (or co-writing) not only Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass and Level-Five Writing Accident, but also A Case of Chiaroscuro, Four-and-a-Half Vulcans, A Space Adventure Hour, and Subspace Rhapsody… basically every episode of the series that I detest or dislike. Horgan does have a couple of semi-redeeming episodes in her repertoire: Ad Astra Per Aspera and New Life and New Civilizations. But neither of those are what I’d call “all-time classics;” they’re not bad, but they’re not spectacular, either.

And I don’t like to call out individuals on the creative side, I think that’s a pretty weak thing to do most of the time. And I especially don’t like to come across as being one of *those* Trekkies, either – the folks who hyperfixate on “the minutiae of canon” or who seem to have absolutely no sense of humour. But honestly… if there’s one positive to Strange New Worlds wrapping up, and to a new batch of creative folks potentially joining Skydance-Paramount to work on Star Trek, it’s that people like Dana Horgan will be on the way out. “But it was all just a dream” is, in my view, the single worst ending to any Star Trek episode ever, and Horgan and co-writer Henry Alonso Myers deserve *all* of the criticism they’re getting for that – and then some.

Pair of photos (cropped) showing Dana Horgan and Henry Alonso Myers (Star Trek SNW writer/producers)
Dana Horgan (left) and Henry Alonso Myers were responsible for a Level-Five Writing Accident.

Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass was the “soap opera episode,” but more so than with any other parody or spoof (or “big swing,” if you want to use their terminology) this time around… it felt pretty mean-spirited and bad-natured. Say what you will about A Case of Chiaroscuro or Human Best Friend; stories like those fully embraced the genres they were part of and went for it in an earnest and honest way. Results will vary when you so openly attempt to take a series to such extremes, I guess… but at least stories like that felt good-natured.

But the longer I’ve had to sit with Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass, the more genuinely mean-spirited, aggressive, and nasty it seems. Rather than respectful homage, the episode crossed a line, seeming to point and laugh at soap opera tropes and clichés – and, by extension, the folks who make those kinds of shows and the audiences that love them. Given that Deidre Hall, a famous American soap actress, was invited to have a guest-starring role, I think that feels even worse. I can only imagine what she (and her co-stars on Days of Our Lives) made of the finished product.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Deidre Hall at her trailer
Deidre Hall.

Captain Pike spent much of the season relegated to a supporting role, which is not something I wanted to see from “the Captain Pike show” that many of us were pestering CBS to make a few years ago. And unfortunately, his two major moments in the spotlight – in the season premiere and the aforementioned soap spoof – came in weak, muddled stories that didn’t have enough time to do anything serious with his character.

If there’s one thing I want to see fixed in Season 5, it’s Pike’s disappearing act.

Strange New Worlds has now had two episodes which I think we can argue were “backdoor pilots” for the failed Year One spin-off idea: Season 3’s The Sehlat Who Ate Its Tail and Season 4’s Tomorrow’s Enterprise. So can we *please* check that item off the bucket list? We don’t need to spend even more time with Kirk as he prepares to take command; as fun and enjoyable as Paul Wesley has been in the role… this isn’t his show. It was Anson Mount’s Captain Pike that people were most eager to see more of – he’s why this series even exists. But Pike has been repeatedly sidelined and ignored, even in stories where he could’ve had more to do or a bigger role to play, in order to turn Strange New Worlds into the prequel show that it was never meant to be.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Wesley and director Christ Fisher
Director Chris Fisher with Paul Wesley on the set of Tomorrow’s Enterprise.

The original appeal of Strange New Worlds wasn’t that it would be a TOS prequel. In one of my first-ever posts discussing the series – before we’d even gotten so much as a teaser, a logo, or casting announcements – I said that I’d encourage the team to tread carefully when it came to introducing too many TOS characters in main roles. And it’s really unfortunate that most of the show’s unique and original creations – Hemmer, Pelia, Ortegas, and La’an – have been sidelined or seen their screen time reduced. Even the likes of Dr M’Benga, Una/Number One, and Sam Kirk have played second fiddle to characters who have major roles in The Original Series, a trend that has only accelerated in Season 4.

I would have been happy if Strange New Worlds didn’t do much of the prequel stuff outside of one or two characters – Spock, obviously, and I’ve enjoyed Uhura’s prequel arc, too. The final episode of a series like that could’ve been the handover from Pike to Kirk – something I think we’re still likely to see in Season 5 – but the rest of the show could’ve been much more of a standalone thing. However, looking back on it, the decision to bring in characters like Uhura and Chapel, and later Kirk and Scotty… well, it speaks to a production team that never really understood what it was fans wanted to see, or what the appeal of a series like this was in the first place.

Still frame from a 2021 commercial for Paramount+ showing Captain Pike (Anson Mount)
Anson Mount (as Captain Pike) in a 2021 Super Bowl commercial.

But okay, rather than lamenting decisions taken years ago, let’s consider where Strange New Worlds actually is today – and what its final episodes can and should look like.

I want to set out a major red line right now: Pike’s accident, disability, and the subsequent mission to Talos IV (as depicted in The Menagerie) should be completely off the table. Between TOS and Discovery Season 2 we’ve seen all we needed to see of that, and although we know Pike’s ultimate destination, we don’t need a re-hashing of it with only six episodes left.

There are bound to be complications and explosions along the way, but for me, I still want the final scenes of Strange New Worlds to show Pike in command, on the bridge, ordering his crew – Ortegas, La’an, Una, and so on – to set course for parts unknown one final time.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Melissa Navia and a cactus
Melissa Navia with her cactus counterpart…

Do I think that’s remotely likely, though? Well… that’s a different question!

The Season 3 epilogue – which was created before a fourth season renewal had been greenlit – gives me a flicker of hope. The very end of Season 3 saw basically what I’ve just described: Pike in command, the crew ready for orders, and the Enterprise warping away to a new, unseen adventure. That, I think, is how a series like Strange New Worlds needs to end… and I’m at least a little encouraged by the fact that the creative team seem to have agreed with me, at least as of Season 3.

But given that the end of the show was known in advance, I expect Season 5 to be structured quite differently. My gut instinct is still to say that it’ll basically be a “six-hour movie;” six fully-serialised episodes building to an explosive conclusion. But even if it’s more episodic than that, I still think we’re gonna get a lot more Kirk, a lot more TOS characters, a lot more “foreshadowing” and prequel storylines… and a lot less of Pike and the show’s original creations.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing a costume rack
A rack of costumes backstage.

Moreover, I really fear that Season 5 is going to try to re-tell some (or perhaps even *all*) of The Menagerie, beginning with Pike’s accident.

I don’t want “The Menagerie, Part III” or any other kind of Menagerie redux. After we saw in Discovery’s second season – and re-emphasised in the brilliant Season 1 finale, too – Pike’s accident and the disability that followed, we simply don’t need to do that again. It would be repetitive, it wouldn’t add anything to the character or his arc on the series, and while it remains Pike’s ultimate destination, we’ve already seen what that looks like in different ways – going back some sixty years.

Given the weaknesses on the writing side, though… I’m genuinely worried that Season 5 will end by re-telling the accident aboard the J-class ship that ultimately crippled Captain Pike. For writers of this quality level, there’s surely gonna be a temptation to say “oh, that’s where the character’s storyline ends up, so let’s just… do it again.” And given everything we’ve just been saying about TOS characters taking over major roles and pushing out the show’s original creations… that storyline could be the *only* one that Captain Pike gets in the entire season.

Behind-the-scenes photo from Star Trek Discovery S2 showing Pike's wheelchair
Discovery’s second season already showed us Pike’s fate. We don’t need to see it again.

After Tomorrow’s Enterprise purportedly showed us a time-jump of just one year into the future, I also can’t help but wonder whether Season 5 is basically gonna pick up *there* instead. The very first scene could be Pike relinquishing command, with Kirk taking over – and Pike’s main (or only) story in the entire season could be that re-telling of parts of Discovery and The Menagerie. That would be… well, I think that would just be awful.

I also expect to see several characters shuffled off-stage pretty early on in Season 5. We’ve already seen that Ortegas departs the Enterprise to take up a teaching role – along with a promotion to the rank of Captain – and that Dr M’Benga is diverting more of his time away from the Enterprise, with Drs Boyce and McCoy stepping up to replace him. We already know of two TOS re-casts for Season 5: Thomas Jane as Dr McCoy and Kai Murakami as Sulu. I adored Thomas Jane in the sci-fi series The Expanse, but Dr McCoy and Sulu being present could indicate that both Dr M’Benga and Ortegas won’t be a big part of the show next time around.

Thomas Jane (left) will play Dr McCoy in Season 5, and Kai Murakami will play Sulu.

Then we have Pelia. In the episode Once La’an A Time, Pelia apparently chose to remain behind aboard the Elysian Kingdom’s flying planet-ship… but we didn’t see that for ourselves, we got no goodbye from Pelia, and I really hope that very poor exposition dump won’t be the last we see or hear of her. But, again, given Scotty’s rise to prominence… well, I can’t help but feel he’s going to be taking over for any and all engineering storylines. Re-introducing Pelia for an episode or two, only to have her leave again arguably doesn’t make a lot of sense… but her departure was so pathetically lacklustre that almost *anything* would be better than another character just telling us, in a throwaway line, that she’s gone away to live on a farm upstate.

I’ve said several times across Season 4 that La’an is the top of my “death watch” list going into Season 5, and that hasn’t changed. If anything, the finale – particularly Kirk’s reaction to her name being mentioned and his subsequent refusal to discuss her – ramped up the idea that, if anyone isn’t gonna make it all the way to the end, it’s gonna be La’an. There are multiple ways this could go, though I think the “latent augment DNA” angle that Season 4 introduced may have been as resolved as it’s gonna get. A heroic death of some kind, perhaps in a fight against the Gorn, could be on the agenda for her.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Peck, Chong, and Wesley with co-stars
Christina Chong (second right) with her co-stars during production on The Griffin Incident.

Una is another character who I think could realistically be killed off. She was absent from the future timeline in Tomorrow’s Enterprise, but more significantly, perhaps, she played no role in helping Pike in The Menagerie. You could make the exact same case for several of Pike’s friends and shipmates, of course… but Una seems like someone willing to bend the rules enough to help. I guess I’d rank her just below La’an on my “death watch” list.

Una is also the main character who I feel Strange New Worlds has done the least with. After we learned in Season 1 that she’s an Illyrian, Season 2 put her on trial… and then she’s mostly been confined to smaller roles ever since. Her big outing in Season 4 came in A Case of Chiaroscuro, the noir-inspired episode, and although it wasn’t really “my thing,” I can appreciate that it was a solid spotlight for her. But look back at past iterations of Star Trek: the ship’s XO would usually have a bigger role in more stories. Una is basically Strange New Worlds’ Chakotay!

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Romijn, Mount, and Goldsman
Rebecca Romijn (Una) and Anson Mount with executive producer Akiva Goldsman.

Chapel’s storylines have been increasingly tied to Dr M’Benga, and I think we’re gonna get something from the two of them as the doctor prepares to scale back his role. We could see, perhaps, Chapel’s first run-in with Dr McCoy – or there could be history between them that they’ll have to work through. That kinda thing is what I’d expect to see from Chapel in Season 5.

Uhura, as I’ve noted more than once, got the best and most complete prequel arc. We saw her go from an uncertain cadet to a confident officer – the embodiment of Nichelle Nichols’ character. And honestly, after *two* major spotlights in the second half of Season 4… I kinda feel like we don’t need any more from Uhura, to be blunt about it – especially if Season 5 has fewer episodes to play with. Her arc was basically complete as of Orders of Magnitude; Tomorrow’s Enterprise was the cherry on top.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Gooding on set
Celia Rose Gooding during a break in filming on Season 4.

Spock… is a tough one, to be honest.

Strange New Worlds’ writers seem to have settled on one idea for Spock, and one only: “hey, aren’t these autistic-coded Vulcans all stuck-up, repressed, and weird? That’s just hilarious!” The result of that has been four seasons of “Spock comedy,” with very little by way of serious storylines for one of Star Trek’s most beloved and iconic characters. *Some* of that has been okay – I liked, for example, seeing Spock hallucinating plants in Human Best Friend. But it’s undeniably been too much of the same thing, as well as too much out-of-character stuff for Spock in these forty episodes.

So, as I’ve said more than once, if the writers really can’t think of anything else for Spock to do… it’s okay to use him in smaller roles. Don’t put him front-and-centre if another slapstick farce is the only thing they’re willing to write (or are capable of writing). I’d rather not see Spock at all than see more “Vulcan comedy” in Season 5.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S2 showing Peck and Kane
Ethan Peck with Carol Kane in a behind-the-scenes snap.

There are a couple of secondary characters I’d like to see get some kind of story beat or sendoff. Sam Kirk, sadly, was relegated to playing second fiddle to his brother in stories where a Kirk was present – even though his scientific role could (and should) have been used more often. I’d like to see him get some kind of goodbye, even if it’s just a short scene as he departs the Enterprise to be with his family.

Then we have Mitchell, who was absent in Season 4 for some reason. It would be nice to see her back on the bridge – perhaps alongside Sulu, just to get another of those threads of continuity. Now that we know her step-brother is Where No Man Has Gone Before’s Gary Mitchell… maybe there’s something the series could do with that. I doubt we’ll see transporter chief Kyle or other secondary bridge characters; most of those haven’t been seen since Seasons 2 or 3, and didn’t play major roles anyway.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S1 showing empty bridge/helm consoles
Part of the bridge set – the helm/navigation consoles.

Finally, we have T’Pring and Admiral April. T’Pring is a Spock-centric character, and I’d argue that they’ve basically gone through every possible relationship drama storyline that Strange New Worlds might invent. A short, minor role for T’Pring could be okay, but I don’t think it’s really necessary at this point. And, again, the writers’ love for “Spock comedy” is not something we need more of!

We know that Admiral April will be present in Season 5 in some form – I’d expect it would be him to offer Pike a promotion, perhaps paving the way for the changeover at the top of the Enterprise’s crew. Whether that’ll come at the end, the beginning, or in the middle… who can say? But we seem to have at least one more adventure with Admiral April on the agenda before the series wraps up.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S5 showing Peck, Holmes, Mount, and Romijn posing for a photo
Adrian Holmes (second left) with Ethan Peck, Anson Mount, and Rebecca Romijn during production on Season 5.

If I were to lump all of Season 4’s episodes into categories… here’s how I’d do it.

In the category I’m calling “irredeemably awful,” we have Level-Five Writing Accident – largely due to its atrocious ending, an ending that would’ve made a primary school teacher roll their eyes and that should’ve been nowhere near a big-budget TV production. And the second episode in this category is Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass, not only for squandering a genuinely relatable and emotional story for Captain Pike (and wasting Anson Mount’s best performance of the season), but also for how mean-spirited and *nasty* it was in the way it targeted the genre it was spoofing.

In the “boring, mid, and just generally not great” category, we have three episodes: Valles Marineris, A Case of Chiaroscuro, and Once La’an A Time. I will re-watch none of these episodes, probably – certainly not for a very long time – and they’re all some combination of forgettable, overstuffed, uninspired, or simply disappointing in various ways. I was particularly upset that the “dinosaur episode” that had been teased in a lot of pre-season marketing material turned out to be such a dud.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Christina Chong on a horse
Christina Chong on horseback while filming Valles Marineris.

That leads us to the category titled “fun but flawed,” which contains a single episode: The Griffin Incident. Another episode let down by its ending – or, in this case, the absolute lack of an ending. The Griffin Incident is genuinely one of Star Trek’s best-ever horror stories… for the first fifty minutes or so. Then Captain Pike comes in, sits down with La’an and basically says “who cares what happened, maybe someone else can figure it out, but I honestly don’t give a shit.” And you know what? If that’s how the writers wanted the episode to “end,” I guess I don’t give a shit either.

The next category is “solid B-plus.” And this category also contains just one episode: Tomorrow’s Enterprise, the season finale. It was a bit unnecessary to do a second Uhura spotlight, given that her arc already felt complete, and I don’t think Strange New Worlds needed a *second* backdoor pilot for its failed spin-off. But it was a rare unicorn of an episode insofar as it’s a time travel/time loop paradox… that I didn’t hate. I enjoyed it pretty much the whole way through, and while it’s not the best of the series or the season… it was pretty good for what it was.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing a Caitian mask
Did you spot M’Ress in Tomorrow’s Enterprise?

Finally, we come to the “cream of the crop.” These three episodes – Human Best Friend, Off-Hour, and Orders of Magnitude – hit all of the right notes for me personally, and I think all three did what they set out to do exceptionally well. Human Best Friend was a send-up of “stoner comedies” like Dude, Where’s My Car and The Hangover, and even though I know I’m in the minority here… I thought it was great fun for what it was. Star Trek doesn’t always need to be 100% serious, and when it fully leans into comedy – and the comedy doesn’t get in the way of anything else – it can be fantastic.

Off-Hour felt like “Strange New Worlds does TNG’s Disaster,” and while I argued there might’ve been more creative ways to use some of the characters (and that the drama was dialled a notch or two too high in places), it was a tense, exciting, and just plain fun ride all the way through. Orders of Magnitude had that great Uhura spotlight, as mentioned, and I also enjoyed the “badmiral” on Kirk’s side of the story, too.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S4 showing Joe Morton as Badmiral Reeger
Joe Morton (Admiral Reeger) being filmed for Orders of Magnitude.

As we look ahead to Season 5… well, I see some glimmers of hope, but quite a few reasons to be pessimistic, I’m sorry to say. A generally disappointing fourth season had basically four watchable episodes, four pieces of fluff, and two level-five writing accidents that should never have made it even halfway through the production process. If Season 5 is to be an improvement… we need some pretty major changes. And unfortunately, production has already wrapped. There’s no time for the team to take on board *any* feedback.

And that leaves me worried.

I am, however, crossing my fingers and hoping for the best. At its peak, Strange New Worlds can still be a fantastic series, full of that spirit of adventure and that elusive “Star Trek-ness” that Trekkies like you and I love to see. A few episodes this season managed to absolutely nail that feeling… and I still want more.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S5 showing the main cast
The main cast during production on Season 5.

I’m concerned that Season 5 is going to double- and triple-down on turing Strange New Worlds into “The Original Series Season 0,” with Kirk in command, the show’s original characters taking a back seat, and perhaps even trying to replay Pike’s accident as a way to end his arc. But that isn’t what I want to see – or what I *ever* wanted to see from this series.

I’m glad, despite some misfires in Season 4, that Strange New Worlds has tried to take Star Trek back to its episodic roots. This franchise – more than any other, really – needs the freedom that only episodic television can bring. The Enterprise needs to be able to warp away to a new planet, a new alien, and a new adventure pretty much every week. And after seasons of Picard, Discovery, Starfleet Academy, and even Prodigy were forced into a modern, serialised streaming TV mould… it’s been a breath of fresh air to get a Star Trek show that embraces that more episodic style.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S5 showing the empty bridge set
The empty bridge set.

Unfortunately, that freedom has led to some silly – and some downright moronic – story ideas. Season 4 seems to have brought the worst of these to the fore… which I *hope* is indicative of the writers and production team getting their more “creative” ideas out of their systems ahead of Season 5! But that might be a plain and simple “cope,” and the truth is… I’m not especially optimistic, at this stage, that Season 5 won’t go even harder on the “big swings,” spoofs, and parodies.

I’m also concerned that Season 5 might end up being wholly serialised – perhaps akin to a “six-hour movie” to round off the series. If that happens, the single story being told will have to be exceptional, and if there’s one word I would *not* use to describe most of the writing in Season 4… it would be “exceptional.” So, again, that’s a big concern.

Serialised stories can work in Star Trek, don’t get me wrong… but my confidence in the writers is shaken right now, and if Strange New Worlds just kind of fizzles out with an unspectacular (or outright *bad*) six-episode finale, that’ll be a major disappointment.

Behind-the-scenes photo from the set of Star Trek SNW S5 showing a clapper board
That’s a wrap.

So that’s how I see things as Season 5 looms on the horizon!

If and when we get more information about Season 5, or if we see a trailer or a teaser clip at next month’s Comic-Con, for example, I’ll do my best to break it down here on the website. I may revisit some of these points, revising or even rescinding them if pre-season trailers and marketing material look better than ever. And I never *want* Star Trek to be bad – especially not a series like Strange New Worlds, which has been my favourite show of the current streaming era. I just can’t shake some of these concerns and worries right now, given how badly large parts of Season 4 landed.

Thanks for joining me for this look ahead, and I hope this has been interesting. I know it hasn’t been “fun,” but sometimes that’s the way it goes in the Trekkie community, eh? Stay tuned, because I’m hoping to write up re-watches of Strange New Worlds Season 1 between now and when Season 5 airs, and I’m sure I’ll have more to say about the show soon, too. If you missed my Season 4 episode reviews, you can find all of them on my dedicated Strange New Worlds page right here on the website. Click or tap here to check it out. There are reviews for all of Seasons 2 and 3, as well, along with other commentary, theories, and discussion pieces. Thanks again for reading, and as always… Live Long and Prosper, friends!


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4 are available to stream now on Paramount+ in countries and territories where the platform is available. The first three seasons are also available on DVD and/or Blu-ray. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds and all other properties discussed above – is the copyright of the Skydance-Paramount corporation. Behind-the-scenes set photos courtesy of Skydance-Paramount/Paramount+/Star Trek on social media. This review contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Episode Review – Season 4, Episode 9: Once La’an A Time

A Star Trek-themed spoiler warning

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: The Original Series, Deep Space Nine, Voyager, and Discovery.

A whimsical fairytale, a sequel to a Season 1 episode, and La’an wrangling with her feelings and personal history all came together this week in Once La’an A Time. The episode was better than I feared it might be when I saw the promos and read the blurb, though in a season where we’ve been treated to soap opera spoofs and “but it was all just a dream,” to be honest… there’s kind of a low bar! However, this isn’t going to be anyone’s idea of an all-time classic Strange New Worlds story, and with so little time remaining before the series goes off the air for good… I can’t shake the feeling that this kind of “big swing” is, yet again, not something I’d have chosen to indulge in.

I’m also of the opinion – and not for the first time this season, I should say – that this episode crammed too much into its runtime, meaning some ideas really didn’t get much time at all in the spotlight. And while I’m happy to have a La’an-focused episode, and to see her facing off against her own doppelgänger (and various fairytale monsters and tropes), I’m yet again unconvinced that taking a serious, introspective character moment and trying to jam it into the show’s latest pantomime or parody was the right call. Sometimes, playing it straight is just… better.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an sulking
The Incredible Sulk.

That being said, La’an’s story this week felt stronger and just better all around than Pike’s did in Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass – and, again, that’s definitely a low bar, but it’s still a point in this episode’s favour. There were a few contrivances to get La’an into the spotlight – and several missing ingredients, too, when considering Season 1’s The Elysian Kingdom – but when she was there, I at least felt that her struggle and her inner conflict were handled better than Pike’s grief had been in the soap opera spoof episode.

However, despite La’an working through her issues and getting a resolution to her lingering family/ancestry/anger issues… the way these issues were set up earlier in the season (and at the beginning of this episode, too) was poor. In addition, La’an’s arc has taken her backwards in one sense – back to a relationship of some kind with Kirk, something she already wrangled with and eventually moved past in Season 2. And finally, because of the episode’s fairytale and almost pantomime theming, some of the more complex, nuanced, and serious ideas that this kind of storyline *could* have offered were either entirely absent or just muddied by the earnest and complete way that Strange New Worlds leaps into these kinds of genre parodies.

As you can see… a bit of a mixed bag, then!

Photo of Henry Alonso Myers, Rebecca Romijn, Ethan Peck, and Christina Chong at a Star Trek SNW event in 2026
L-R: Henry Alonso Myers, Rebecca Romijn, Ethan Peck, and Christina Chong at a recent Star Trek event in the United States.

We’ll deal with other aspects of the episode, as well as the other characters (and their doppelgängers) first, and save La’an for the end. There’s more to say for her storyline (obviously), so structuring the review that way makes the most sense to me!

In terms of visuals, and the way Once La’an A Time was presented, I really don’t have anything bad to say. I liked the costumes – some, but not all, of which were recycled from The Elysian Kingdom – and there were some creative and fun locales to visit when the away team were on the fairytale planet. Most of these were tropes of the genre, of course, but the way things like the castle and the swamp were brought to the screen were generally well done. Werewolf-Kirk was also a highlight!

When it came to the episode’s climactic stand-off between the dragon and the Enterprise, if you set aside the inherent silliness of the premise, the fight itself looked pretty darn cool. And the Uhura-dragon, while perhaps not as visually impressive as something from the likes of Game of Thrones, was pretty intimidating. It made for an exciting final act, and Uhura’s doppelgänger transforming, like Sleeping Beauty’s Maleficent, was a fun – albeit tropey – way for the story to take its one-dimensional villain.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing the Uhura-dragon
The Uhura-dragon.

I’m in two minds about Pelia’s story this week – and I’m crossing my fingers and *hoping* that this won’t be her final appearance.

The final mention of Pelia in Once La’an A Time was from Captain Pike telling us that Pelia chose to remain behind aboard the Elysian Kingdom planet-ship-thing, and that *immediately* rang alarm bells for me. Firstly, if this is going to be Pelia’s swansong, she didn’t even say goodbye or get a single moment with… anyone. Not Pike, not Una, not Scotty, no one at all. So there’s no closure for this fun character and no proper send-off.

And secondly, after Pelia had gotten a pretty fun storyline (or a collection of fun smaller moments, I guess) in Once La’an A Time, she disappeared quite abruptly. I would’ve liked to have seen Pelia learning more about how the ship worked, working with some of the denizens of the fantasy world, and figuring things out. In fact, I’d have happily enjoyed an entire *episode* based around Pelia, Scotty, and an Enterprise engineering team working on a strange, otherworldly, and distinctly alien craft. That would’ve been fun.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Pelia at a desk
I really hope this isn’t the last time we’ll see Pelia.

If, however, this isn’t a poorly-written way to get Pelia off the show, and a proper goodbye will happen later on, then I guess I can rescind that line of criticism somewhere down the line.

Based on what we got, I thought Pelia had another really fun moment in the spotlight this week. She’s been one of my favourite characters since she was introduced – though still, sadly, she hasn’t had a full episode or spent as much time on screen as I’d have liked! But Pelia was a great fit for a story like this, and I liked how her absence from Season 1 not only wasn’t a hindrance, but actually worked to everyone’s advantage. That was a creative way to acknowledge that she was missing from Season 1 while incorporating it into the story.

There was, I felt, a potential role for Hemmer here. Bruce Horak, who played Hemmer in Season 1, reprised his role in illusory form in Season 2, and also played a Klingon commander later in the season, so he clearly has been up for a return in the past. It could’ve added a completely different dimension to the story if, in addition to having to deal with strange doppelgängers, Pike and co. also had to confront the living, breathing embodiment of a deceased friend. Given Pike’s arc a couple of weeks back, dealing with grief and loss, that could’ve even been thematically relevant.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 1x08 showing M'Benga and Hemmer
There could’ve been a role for Hemmer this time…

However! Rather than lamenting what we *didn’t* get – and for all I know, Bruce Horak may have declined such an offer if one had even been attempted – let’s return to Pelia.

Season 1 established that Benny Russell (a reference to Benjamin Sisko’s alter ego in the Deep Space Nine episode Far Beyond the Stars) was the author of the original Elysian Kingdom book. And Pelia being assigned that role – because she was new and hadn’t been part of the original group of doppelgängers – made sense. I liked that we got that little callback to DS9; at this point, as a huge DS9 and Sisko fan, I’ll take whatever crumbs I can get!

Because she’s a light-hearted and whimsical character who almost never seems to be bothered or thrown off by any of the shenanigans that the Enterprise gets into, Pelia was a great choice to bring into a fairytale story like this. I loved her line near the beginning about how she always misses out on the fun stuff; could that be a tiny bit self-referential, too, given Pelia’s sparse appearances across the three seasons she’s nominally been a part of? I wonder!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Pelia with Pike and Spock
Pelia with Pike and Spock.

On a more serious note, I want to take a diversion to Dr M’Benga.

This week, Dr M’Benga played a very minor role, dumping a bunch of exposition onto Pike and the away team, catching them (and us as the audience) up on the events of The Elysian Kingdom. But because that episode and its story had been so important to Dr M’Benga’s entire Season 1 arc – and literally saw him lose his only daughter – I can’t help but feel that we should’ve seen more from him, gotten some kind of acknowledgement of how this was all making *him* feel, or done more to reference what happened to Rukiya.

And maybe… the fact that Once La’an A Time couldn’t do that means that this specific narrative framework wasn’t a great idea.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Dr M'Benga
The Elysian Kingdom was a Dr M’Benga story… but its direct sequel sidelined him.

There are a million-and-one ways that La’an could’ve confronted her inner demons, her lingering feelings about her ancestry, and her childhood trauma. It didn’t *need* to come in the form of this pantomime thing, and given that The Elysian Kingdom was such an important episode for Dr M’Benga, and how Rukiya had chosen to stay with the entity (and was, therefore, presumably present in some form aboard the planet-ship-thing), it feels profoundly *odd* that Dr M’Benga played functionally no role in the episode whatsoever beyond “lore dump.”

And I realise that we’re yet again tackling what *wasn’t* present in the episode rather than what actually was, but don’t you think it’s a very strange omission? The Elysian Kingdom may not have been everyone’s favourite part of Season 1 (which makes it kind of an odd choice for a sequel, if you think about it), but it was a very important story for Dr M’Benga. If we’re talking about themes of family trauma, children losing their parents and parents losing their children, and coming face to face with complex and difficult emotions… why was Dr M’Benga relegated to this incredibly minor role when his only daughter – someone he was willing to make all manner of sacrifices for – could’ve been right there?

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 1x08 showing Rukiya and Dr M'Benga
Dr M’Benga with Rukiya in Season 1.

To me, this reads kind of like Strange New Worlds’ writers not really knowing what they were doing. They wanted to do a (second) fairytale-inspired story, so a return to the basic world of The Elysian Kingdom must’ve seemed – superficially, at least – like a good fit. Only, the character they wanted to shine a spotlight on this time was La’an, and with other fairytale nonsense going on for Pike, Spock, and Pelia… there was no effort made to include Dr M’Benga at all.

Given that basically nothing in Once La’an A Time would’ve changed if this had been a *different* doppelgänger-populated fairytale planet… why bother calling back to The Elysian Kingdom at all? The only characters who really behaved like their Season 1 counterparts were Pike, as the cowardly knave, and La’an, as the spoiled princess. The rest of the characters were so one-dimensional as to be little more than fluff, and the whole “iron dragon” prophecy was also brand-new to the setting. There was a pathway to telling not just a similar story, but this *exact* story (if someone had decided it was worth telling) without complicating Dr M’Benga’s arc from back in Season 1. And while I get that those events are a few years ago, it wasn’t a great episode, not everyone is gonna remember it all, and blah, blah, blah… it still feels odd to me that we’d revisit this exact setting, where Dr M’Benga’s beloved daughter presumably still resides, and he would get absolutely no role in that story whatsoever.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing the USS Enterprise/iron dragon
The “iron dragon.”

Strange New Worlds’ writers seem to have a penchant for throwing the main cast into silly situations which force them to take on either completely new roles or else play different versions of themselves. We’ve had five just this season: the evil doppelgängers in The Griffin Incident, the drunk or drugged characters from Human Best Friend, the dream puppets in Level-Five Transporter Accident, the soap opera in Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass, and now these pantomime/fairytale characters this week. And that comes after some or all of the main cast were acting out-of-character in: Spock Amok and The Elysian Kingdom in Season 1, Among The Lotus Eaters, Charades, and Subspace Rhapsody in Season 2, and Wedding Bell Blues, A Space Adventure Hour and Four-and-a-Half Vulcans in Season 3.

That’s thirteen out of a total of forty-six episodes – more than a quarter of the entire show’s run – in which a major storyline involves one or more of the show’s main characters being duplicated, transformed, changed, or forced to act out-of-character.

If you’re a regular reader, you might remember an article here on the website a few months back, written in response to the news that Starfleet Academy had been cancelled and that, consequently, no new Star Trek was in production for the first time in a decade. I said then that one potential upside to the franchise taking a bit of a break could be an injection of fresh blood and new talent on the production side; people with new, different, and creative ideas for where to take Star Trek in the future. Given how repetitive Strange New Worlds has been with this “isn’t it funny when people don’t act like themselves” schtick, well… case in point, eh?

Concept art from Star Trek SNW 1x08 showing Runa the dog
Concept art of Runa the dog from Season 1.

Pike and Spock – or rather, their fairytale doppelgängers – got a reasonably fun side-story as they schemed to take over the “iron dragon.” I think you have to work *hard* to suspend your disbelief for parts of this one; the idea that the likes of Una, Ortegas, and Uhura (as well as dozens of crew members in the bar) wouldn’t notice that the people in front of them weren’t *really* Pike and Spock – when they knew for a fact that they’re orbiting a planet of doppelgängers – takes a bit of effort to push out of your mind! And for some Trekkies, especially the detail-oriented canon sticklers, I can see that being a bridge too far.

For me, though, when I got into the flow of Pike and Spock’s silly pantomime thing, I was content to go along for the ride. There might’ve been a way to do a bit more with this idea, and the way it just kind of disappeared right at the end did feel quite abrupt. But in terms of what we actually got, it was okay, and there were some genuinely fun moments as the doppelgängers tried to blend in with the crew, but just weren’t able to do so. If you think of it as a campier, sillier take on Mirror, Mirror’s core concept, I guess it’s fine.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Pike and Spock's doppelgangers
The doppelgängers.

The decision to pair up Una and Ortegas’ doppelgängers felt a bit… forced. It felt like the writers were aware that Strange New Worlds hasn’t had much by way of LGBT+ themes or characters and decided to use the excuse of “but they’re just doppelgängers” to throw something like that in. Compare it to Deep Space Nine’s Rejoined, where Jadzia Dax gets a same-sex parnter storyline, or even episodes in Discovery with Culber and Stamets, and it really just feels tokenistic.

Una and Ortegas – the real versions of their characters, at least – have absolutely no romantic chemistry whatsoever; they’re work friends, not even particularly close friends – or at least that’s how I’ve always interpreted their relationship. So it wasn’t even like this was a great choice of characters to pair up; there’d have been more chemistry between, say, Kirk and Scotty’s doppelgängers or even Chapel and Uhura’s.

And that reminds me: did Scotty not get a doppelgänger? Seems a shame to leave him out!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Una and Ortegas' doppelgangers
The kiss.

I’ll lump all of the other doppelgängers together, because they all felt incredibly one-note and basic; pantomime caricatures rather than real people. Uhura’s was just an “evil queen” trope that you’ll see in countless stories from Snow White to Narnia and beyond. Chapel’s was basically a sillier take on the insidious advisor or wicked witch who props up an evil ruler. La’an’s – despite her importance to the main character’s story – was a cheap damsel in distress, M’Benga’s doppelgänger got literally no screen time at all, and Kirk’s was, again, just a typical fairytale swashbuckler.

We’ll get into Kirk in more detail in a moment, though.

As I said above, this is the thirteenth episode (out of a total of forty-six that the series is gonna get) where characters behave unnaturally or where main cast members have to play completely different people. And that idea has *already* worn out its welcome, to be blunt. In isolation, there’s nothing wrong with doing a fairytale panto, or even doing a sequel to Season 1’s fairytale panto. But this is not merely the first or second time we’ve been here, and when the doppelgängers are all so exceptionally boring, tropey, bland, forgettable, and basic, and behave like the most one-dimensional clichés… well, it’s got old already. Thankfully, most of them weren’t on screen long enough to *properly* irk me, and I can appreciate that this episode gave (almost) everyone something to do. But it’s my sincere hope that we won’t be back to this overdone story idea again. In fact, if Star Trek makes a triumphant return to the small screen a few years down the line, Strange New Worlds’ overuse of these “everyone’s acting out-of-character” or “aren’t these doppelgängers just hilarious?” ideas should be enough to make any similar episode pitch receive an immediate “no” from the new production team!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Pike and Spock in the dungeon
Let’s not have any more “out-of-character” storylines, eh?

Earlier this season, I felt that La’an’s “latent augment DNA” thing wasn’t set up particularly strongly. The best that we got from this storyline came in The Griffin Incident, though, and by that point I thought there was merit in exploring the idea that La’an might be struggling – or might be about to face something bigger, something that could even lead to the end of her time aboard the Enterprise.

I will be honest: I could not have predicted *this* kind of episode being the culmination of that arc!

However, I’m sticking to my guns in one sense: I still think, somehow, that La’an might not be long for this world. Allow me to explain!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Princess La'an drinking from a goblet
Chug! Chug! Chug!

What’s the point of getting Kirk and La’an back together a mere seven episodes from the end of the series? La’an doesn’t have any role (that we know of) aboard the Enterprise by the time Kirk assumes command. And for both of their character arcs – Kirk’s prequel arc and La’an’s overall arc across the show – they’d already been through this and come to a resolution. But what if one episode, either at the end of Season 4 or sometime in Season 5, is going to see Kirk having to deal with La’an’s death?

And for La’an, there’d be something quietly tragic about a character having finally gotten to a place where, in her own words, she might be able to begin to feel “happy,” only for that to be ripped away. Star Trek doesn’t always do character deaths with such brutality, but given where Strange New Worlds is going, I’ve felt really since Season 3 that *at least* one more main character is gonna kick the bucket to make way for their TOS counterparts! And La’an, having set up this “latent augment DNA” idea at the beginning of the season, still feels like candidate number one on my “death watch” list.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an on her date
La’an is still top of my “death watch” list!

But that’s a theory for the future. Let’s concentrate on her arc in Once La’an A Time for now.

Firstly, while there have been moments in Season 4 where La’an has seemed grumpy or standoffish, most of the time she’s just seemed like herself. So that made her “I’m in a bad mood” thing (and apparently punching and kicking people off-screen, too) just not work as well as intended. “Show, don’t tell” is great advice in your first Introduction to Creative Writing class, and I think we needed to *see* more of the way La’an had been feeling – and how those feelings had been causing her to push friends away, damage her relationships, take risks, or just misbehave (for want of a better word) – before we reached this point. Forcing her to confront this complex part of her personality just didn’t seem to get the setup that it needed.

I felt echoes of Voyager’s first-season episode Faces, as well as the TOS classic The Enemy Within, in the way La’an had to come face-to-face with a side of herself that she’s been trying to suppress. And there is undeniably merit in the idea of a character recognising that they need different aspects of their personality working in tandem; that they can’t completely excise an integral part of themselves, no matter how ashamed, frightened, embarrassed, or anxious they might be about it. That’s something Star Trek has *always* done: used a sci-fi lens to tell relatable, meaningful stories. All of us have parts of our past, aspects of our personalities, or something within that we aren’t proud of or don’t want to show to the world, but you can’t entirely cut out that part of yourself without losing something valuable. That’s the message the episode was going for.

Four still frames from Star Trek showing characters meeting their doppelgangers
Meeting your doppelgänger is a trope in Star Trek, apparently!

Whether that message came across as well as intended, though… that’s another matter.

As happened to Pike’s story about grief in Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass – though, thankfully, to a slightly lesser extent – La’an’s story of wrangling with a side of herself she’s frightened of or doesn’t want to acknowledge *was* impacted by the decision to set it amidst this pantomime-fairytale story. The setting, the one-dimensional characters, the silly B-plot aboard the Enterprise… all of those things pulled against what should’ve been the episode’s defining storyline and key character arc.

If this was a one-off; a single episode out of almost forty so far in which the main idea in the episode clashed in a way that was jarring at best and irreconcilable at worst with its setting or narrative, I guess I’d be a little more lenient. But this *exact* issue has reared its head in Strange New Worlds before. Pike had what could’ve been a genuinely relatable story about loss and grief… but a soap opera spoof that didn’t even feel particularly respectful or good-natured shat all over it. And even this episode’s predecessor – The Elysian Kingdom – arguably had the exact same problem with Dr M’Benga and Rukiya; the core idea and theme of loss just couldn’t be made to work with the silly, light-hearted tone of the rest of the script.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an on the transporter pad
Once La’an A Time was an episode at odds with itself.

Look at the Strange New Worlds character pieces that have worked the best: Season 3’s Terrarium, which saw Ortegas dealing with her lingering trauma from the Gorn conflict. Season 2’s Under the Cloak of War, in which Dr M’Benga had to come to terms with his Klingon war experiences when he came face-to-face with a war criminal. And Season 1’s A Quality of Mercy, where Pike had to accept that his impending accident and disability are truly inevitable.

What do these stories have in common? Yes, they’re sci-fi, and yes, they rely on aliens, spaceships, and technobabble in places, but they also take their core, important ideas and play them straight. They don’t force these heavy themes to sit awkwardly atop light-hearted scripts, they aren’t tonally jarring, and because of that… they work a lot better not only at conveying their intended messages, but also as enjoyable, interesting, relatable, and emotional episodes of television, too.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing the USS Enterprise and a dragon
The Enterprise faces off against a dragon…

I think one vital thing we’ve learned from Strange New Worlds is simply this: Star Trek can be hilarious when it leans fully into comedy, and Star Trek can be dramatic, intense, emotional, and educational when it examines important real-world issues and ideas through its sci-fi lens.

But it can’t be both at the same time.

You can’t be a hilarious send-up of soap opera clichés and then try to tack on a serious story about a dad grieving his daughter. You can’t be a serious, introspective character piece about someone coming to terms with who they are as a person only to bury that message in a wacky slapstick plot about dream-puppets or characters turned into Vulcans. And, in this case, you can’t tell a story about La’an wrangling with a part of her personality that she tries to keep buried while at the same time doing a fairytale pantomime. The two ideas simply cannot be made to work together, no matter how hard you try.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an unconscious
La’an unconscious.

The sad thing is that there’s so much in La’an that we *could* have explored if we’d gotten a more focused and serious episode. For me, outside of Season 2’s Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow, Strange New Worlds hasn’t done anywhere near enough to justify making La’an a descendant of the iconic Star Trek villain Khan. Her last name – and what it represents in this fictional world – would have been ripe for an introspective character piece like this. A more focused episode could’ve either gone full sci-fi, with La’an’s latent augment DNA being a metaphor for generational trauma, the burden of ancestry, and so on, or it could’ve been much more literal, with La’an having to confront something that her ancestor did and how it impacted the wider Star Trek universe.

Being a descendant of Khan Noonien Singh in a world that remembers him as an evil tyrant is like being a descendant of any one of a number of real-world dictators and despots. And, more broadly, it could be a metaphor for, say, the children of empire; those of us who grew up in a world shaped by the *bad* decisions of our ancestors. The British Empire did appalling things, the American “Empire” has plenty to answer for, and it could be cathartic to see a fictional character wrangling with the legacy of her ancestor and the lifelong burden that placed upon her.

Still frame from Star Trek II showing a close-up of Khan
La’an is a descendant of Khan… not that it’s ever really mattered to her character.

Strange New Worlds has never really done that – and this feels like it might just have been the last chance to take La’an’s identity, her family legacy, this core part of who she is, and tell a story with it that justified its controversial inclusion.

But because this is “the big swings show,” and because Strange New Worlds just *had* to cram in yet another genre spoof – one it’s literally already done before, in this case – we didn’t get that. Yes, La’an had to confront a part of herself that she doesn’t like. And yes, there was merit in that idea, imperfectly executed though it may have been. But when you stack up what we got against what we could’ve got in a more serious and straight-laced story… I dunno. I’m underwhelmed, I guess.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an taking on her doppelganger
Some La’an-on-La’an action…

I try not to come across as *that* kind of Trekkie; someone who thinks Star Trek should never be light-hearted or that the franchise shouldn’t ever attempt new or fun ideas. And this season, my reviews of Strange New Worlds have tended to be quite critical of some of these genre spoofs and parodies in a way I wouldn’t have wanted. But this time, as in several previous cases across Season 4… I just feel that the silly spoof idea clashed with what could’ve been a genuinely great storyline if it had been taken more seriously. And when the show’s running out of time, and there’s not gonna be time to do everything, sometimes you have to choose one narrative concept or the other. Trying to push two things together didn’t work a couple of weeks ago, and it didn’t work here, either – though Once La’an A Time is, at least, less of a failure than Level-Five Transporter Accident or Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass.

For whatever that’s worth.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Una and Ortegas on the bridge with two doppelgangers
The view from the bridge…

When I mentioned Kirk above, I said that there *could* yet be a payoff to this La’an relationship angle if something like my theory is borne out. However, if we assume that (as usual) my theories are all wrong, then I gotta say that this Kirk-La’an storyline just feels like a waste. Why, after going to so much trouble to give La’an an arc in which she had to get over Kirk, would Strange New Worlds bring her back to him two seasons later? What’s the point? It feels genuinely regressive for her character in a way that I’m struggling to excuse.

It’s also a pretty tropey idea, if you think about it. “Character confronts an internal issue or overcomes some big personal struggle only to celebrate by immediately getting into a relationship” is about as boring an outcome to this kind of storyline as you can possibly get. If – *if* – there’s a bigger narrative function to this relationship, as suggested/theorised above, then we may be able to revisit this episode and judge this ending a bit more kindly in hindsight. But right now? It does not feel great to drag La’an back more than two seasons and throw her into a second Kirk love affair, especially after having just settled her down after her entanglement with Spock came to an end.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Kirk
So we’re doing Kirk and La’an again, are we?

On a more positive note, I will say that Christina Chong (whom I have met!) did a great job playing two very different versions of her character. It can’t be an easy challenge to have to act against oneself – especially when camera trickery and/or CGI are needed to get both versions of “you” into the same scene. La’an and her doppelgänger felt distinct, and their climactic clash was genuinely well-acted, well-choreographed, and landed about as well as it could’ve.

And Chong has great on-screen chemistry with Paul Wesley, both in his guise as “Dashing” and as his more familiar character of Kirk. Even if I’m not wild about the way in which this episode brought the two characters together, the performers work well together, play off each other well, and I can buy into the idea that La’an has a thing for Kirk and that Kirk might just be into her, too.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing Dashing (Kirk) and La'an
Paul Wesley and Christina Chong have good on-screen chemistry.

In terms of the episode itself, La’an gets a character arc that doesn’t start particularly strongly, builds to a reasonably entertaining and interesting climax, before closing with an epilogue that – theories and potential future storylines aside – feels regressive, at least right now. There were fun moments along the way, don’t get me wrong, and werewolf-Kirk taught her a valuable lesson about fully embracing *every* aspect of herself, even the ones she’s tried to run away from or hide from others.

But this arc was not only ill-suited to the kind of fairytale that surrounded it, but the pantomime trappings arguably detracted from the core message that the episode was aiming to tell.

I would’ve happily gone along for a fun pantomime romp, even knowing that a story like that would never be a “top-ten greatest episodes of the series” contender for me. And I would’ve enjoyed and related to a more serious, introspective character piece focusing on La’an and her inner conflict, her struggle with her ancestry, and her lingering trauma from her childhood. But Once La’an A Time struggled – and ultimately failed – to bring these two diametrically-opposed ideas together into a single, cohesive story. And what we got, while a damn sight better than the worst offerings so far this season, is still a bit of a mess.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing La'an with the werewolf
La’an with the were-Kirk.

That being said, Pelia made me smile, seeing the Enterprise facing off against a dragon was visually stunning, were-Kirk will always be a fun metaphor, and Christina Chong stepped up to the plate when it came to taking on a difficult acting challenge. I smiled, chuckled, and even laughed out loud in places, when the episode’s humour hit just right, and as someone who once dabbled in amateur dramatics a long time ago, I can appreciate the episode’s fairytale and pantomime inspirations, even while acknowledging that those elements took away from a more interesting and serious message.

That, in a nutshell, was Once La’an A Time.

I don’t “rank” episodes, nor do I put a numerical value or a letter grade on my reviews! But what I will say is this: in a stronger year, this would undoubtedly be considered the worst episode of the season. It’s only because we’ve had two complete and utter farces already this season – and three other episodes that had notable flaws and weaknesses, too – that Once La’an A Time is spared that ignominy. And the episode is – somewhat perversely, perhaps – given a bit of a boost by those earlier failures; a sense of “well, at least it’s not *that* bad” may have crept in.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x09 showing the dragon setting fire to the saucer section of the Enterprise
Dragon fire!

Thanks for joining me for this review.

Next week is the season finale, Tomorrow’s Enterprise. The episode’s title intrigues me, and although a direct connection to The Next Generation era (and the episode Yesterday’s Enterprise) is all but certain to be off the table, I’m hoping that we’ll at least get a strong, engaging, and just plain *fun* episode to round out the season. Surely, after Season 4 has served up more misses than hits, we can manage to finish strongly! Right?

So I hope you’ll join me again next week for that! If you missed them, I’ve reviewed every Season 4 episode – as well as episodes from Seasons 2 and 3 as well – and you can find all of those by clicking or tapping here. And if you’d like to check out my article celebrating the Star Trek franchise’s sixtieth anniversary, you can find that by clicking or tapping here. See you next week, and as always… Live Long and Prosper, friends!


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4 are available to stream now on Paramount+ in countries and territories where the platform is available. The first three seasons are also available on DVD and/or Blu-ray. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds and all other properties discussed above – is the copyright of the Skydance-Paramount corporation. This review contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Episode Review – Season 4, Episode 7: Like Chronitons Through The Hourglass

A Star Trek-themed spoiler warning.

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: The Original Series, The Final Frontier, and The Next Generation.

At the start of 2026, I wrote that Strange New Worlds’ fourth season was almost certainly a top contender for my coveted “TV Show of the Year” award. But now that we’re seven episodes in, I can put my hand on my heart and say that, honestly? I’ve really only enjoyed two of them.

And, as you might’ve guessed, Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass ain’t one of the two.

I’m kind of in two minds about the episode – and, as we go along, I’ll talk about one way that I think its story could’ve been salvaged, because there was a genuinely emotional story for Captain Pike that I think should’ve gotten more attention. On the one hand, the deliberately melodramatic soap opera stuff was so tacky and awful that I’m left scratching my head as to who thought it was a good idea. (As well as who keeps allowing writer Dana Horgan to remain employed). But on the other, Pike’s arc had merit – at least in theory – and I’m disappointed that this story of grief, loss, and mental health wasn’t explored in more depth and in a better way.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing the fake title card
Yep. We’re really doing this.

I’ve said this before, particularly with Discovery and Picard, but modern Star Trek has been shockingly bad with its depictions of mental health. There have been some genuinely well-intentioned ideas; storylines involving our favourite characters and their struggles that absolutely are worth exploring. But in almost every instance, the execution of these character arcs and narratives have been, in a word, atrocious.

And so it was in Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass with Captain Pike.

It was a good idea to revisit what happened to Pike at the end of Season 3 and explore how losing a partner – and mourning the life they could’ve led – was causing him pain. This is something Star Trek has always done: looking at real-world issues through the lens of science-fiction. In this case, Pike *literally* saw and experienced that alternate life, but if you take it as a metaphor, many, many people have gone through loss, grief, mourning, and reflecting on the possibility of a different outcome and a different life.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike and Juliet
Captain Pike with his daughter.

Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass lets us see this from a different angle with La’an and Spock, too. Captain Pike is literally in mourning; grieving the death of not only Captain Batel but the nonexistence of his daughter, Juliet. La’an, though, is metaphorically “grieving” the end of her romantic relationship with Spock, understanding that their breakup was right for both of them, while still feeling that sense of emptiness and wondering what could’ve been.

Those storylines, had they taken place in a stronger, more grounded narrative framework, were absolutely worth examining. There was a point to be made about loss and grief, and how the end of a relationship can be devastating – even if it was the right decision. For La’an, as she potentially gears up for an exit from the Enterprise (in keeping with the season’s idea of “boldly going one step closer to where it all began”; i.e. moving characters into place in time for The Original Series), that could mean stepping away from the ship to help her move on from Spock (and Kirk, I guess). And for Captain Pike… well, we saw a tiny glimpse at the very end of the episode of how he’s still emotionally wrecked by what happened.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike in therapy
Captain Pike is still reeling from the death of Captain Batel, and the loss of their daughter, Juliet.

The soap opera story, though, completely ruined any chance of those narrative arcs being successfully explored, and I’m genuinely left feeling shocked at the stupidity of the show’s writers and producers – not for the first time this season, I should say. Did they *genuinely* think that this kind of overly-melodramatic soap opera spoof was the best way to examine complex themes of mental health, mourning, grief, loss, and more? What do they think this soap opera stuff added to the story? Could they not recognise that the tone of such a story is in complete contrast to its serious themes?

There are a couple of ways an episode like Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass could’ve been made to work. One would’ve been to lean fully into the soap opera stuff and treat it like a comedy story. Strange New Worlds has done several episodes with overtly comedic premises, and some of them have worked better than others, admittedly, but when they get it right, it works. Look at Human Best Friend earlier this season as an example: it leaned fully into its “Dude, Where’s My Car” and “The Hangover” inspirations, and what resulted was a genuinely fun, light-hearted story.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing four character cards
The soap opera plot detracted from what could and should have been the episode’s core themes.

Alternatively, if the focus of the story was to be on such serious things for two of the show’s main characters, then the soap opera stuff could’ve been limited to short vignettes; we could’ve gotten a taste of Trelane’s meddling but without turning nine-tenths of the episode into a tonally jarring mess.

For me, I think themes as serious as grief and loss really need a dedicated storyline – one that *isn’t* wrapped up in the trappings of Strange New Worlds’ latest genre parody. And I feel the consequences of both modern Star Trek’s cut-down, ten-episode seasons as well as the show’s imminent cancellation in the way two completely, fundamentally incompatible concepts were forced together. The result was a mess; an episode that didn’t know whether it wanted to be silly or serious, tried to be both, and ended up succeeding at neither.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Ortegas
Ortegas.

Two groups of writers and/or producers clearly had competing ideas. One was to revisit Captain Pike’s family from the end of Season 3, and explore these themes of loss, mourning, and how Pike’s imagined reality could be a metaphor for people in the audience who are going through similar grieving processes. And the other idea? “Let’s do a silly soap opera parody with all the dramatic musical stings, close-up shots, and overblown lighting! Won’t that be fun?”

And then, somehow – perhaps because the show only had a few episodes per season, or because cancellation loomed – some utter, abject*moron* decided to put both ideas together into one single episode. Is it a coincidence that both Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass and Level-Five Transporter Accident, with its appalling ending, share a writer? Hmm.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Trelane in the booth
Trelane watches his masterpiece unfold…

If I’d been Strange New Worlds’ showrunner, and two groups of writers had approached me with these ideas, I’d have picked the more serious one. That isn’t because Star Trek can’t be silly, Star Trek shouldn’t do comedy, or even because I don’t like genre parodies. All of those concepts can work in Star Trek, have already worked in Star Trek, and can be a lot of fun. But having already had several overtly comedic stories across the show’s run, *and* with several other “big swings” into different genres already on the books just in Season 4… I think I’d have said “no” to the soap opera and insisted on doing a more in-depth look at the themes on Pike and La’an’s sides of the story in a more straight-laced setting.

There *can* be value in contrast; in juxtaposing a serious idea against an inherently silly setting. But doing that successfully requires finesse, and frankly, it requires a level of production and writing quality that I don’t think either Strange New Worlds or indeed modern Star Trek as a whole have demonstrated themselves to be capable of. Ambition is great! We should all endeavour to be ambitious in our writing and with our creative ideas. But there comes a point where ambition runs into the brick wall of reality, and for me… I think some of the show’s producers and writers need to recognise their own limitations.

Behind-the-scenes photo from Star Trek SNW 4x07
Behind-the-scenes during production.

Maybe a really exceptional writer-director-producer combo could’ve pulled this off. But clearly, no one in the Strange New Worlds writers’ room or on the production side is at that level.

This episode’s writers *certainly* weren’t.

I’m also hyper-aware of the fact that this is now the *second* episode this season – after Level-Five Transporter Accident – where the bulk of the story didn’t “really” happen. Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass’ ending isn’t as bad as “but it was all just a dream” (though let’s be honest: nothing could be as bad as that), but despite leaving the characters with most of their memories of what took place… it still scrubs those events from the show’s internal reality.

Again: that’s pretty fucking weird, isn’t it?

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing the USS Enterprise
The Enterprise is now back to normal.

Maybe there’s supposed to be a point about making emotional connections through fiction, and how the emotions we feel when reading a book or watching an episode of television are no less real just because it was fiction that elicited them. That might be an idea worth exploring – but again, such a concept would require higher-quality writing, a planned narrative arc, and less of a tonal clash between the soap opera silliness and the characters’ real lives.

In a way, I like this idea a lot. My website exists because I find value in fictional worlds like Star Trek; spending more time in those worlds, with those characters, is fun for me and always will be. And I don’t deny the power of all forms of media to evoke strong emotions. The emotional reaction we have to an episode of Star Trek, a movie, a book… those are *real*, even if the stories and characters aren’t. And there’d be value in an exploration of the idea of exploring that kind of emotional connection.

But that isn’t what Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass was going for – and even if it had been, it didn’t work.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Dr M'Benga
Dr M’Benga.

I feel rather sorry for Anson Mount. After being functionally absent for most of Season 4, his first real spotlight ended up being a tonally muddled episode where two clashing ideas just couldn’t be forced together cohesively. That means that what is objectively one of Mount’s best – and certainly his most emotional – performances in the role of Captain Pike came in an episode that’s honestly better left forgotten, for the most part.

Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass managed to hit the right emotional note with Pike… at the tail end of the story. And seeing him break down, expressing those emotions he’d been holding onto since the end of Season 3 genuinely hit me. But they didn’t hit as hard as they might’ve if the rest of the episode had been stronger and more grounded, and because Pike’s moment of emotion came right at the end of the episode, just as the credits were about to roll… I just don’t think it landed as hard as it should have.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike in therapy
Captain Pike breaks down.

If Strange New Worlds wanted to do this kind of story, examining Pike’s mental health and his emotional state after losing Captain Batel and Juliet, then it realistically needed to be part of a completely different narrative framework. Trying to squash genuinely complex emotional storytelling for the man who’s (allegedly) the show’s main character up against this bizarre and over-the-top genre parody didn’t work.

What’s more, it should’ve been obvious from the *concept* stage that these two ideas couldn’t work together, which is why I stand by what I said above: the people who came up with this idea, turned it into a complete script, and greenlit it for full production are stupid, idiotic people who shouldn’t be working in this industry! It was *painful* to watch parts of Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass because of how cringe-inducing it was… and that would be bad enough on its own, but when you add into the mix that there was an actual, genuine story worth telling that the soap opera pastiche shat all over? It’s unforgivably bad, to be blunt.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike (side angle)
There was a story worth telling for Captain Pike (and La’an) that got buried by an unnecessary and over-the-top spoof.

I’m in favour of Star Trek trying new things. And I’m in favour of Star Trek trying out stories in radically different genres and with completely different tones. Part of the franchise’s appeal, at least for me, is its episodic nature, and that the Enterprise can warp away to a new planet, new aliens, a new adventure, and a new kind of story each and every week. I’m not saying “don’t do these kinds of genre stories,” and I’m not saying “Star Trek has to be 100% straight-laced and serious every single time.” That wouldn’t be fun.

But what I am saying, at least in this case, is that the genre parody fundamentally could not work with the more complex themes that the other side of the episode wanted to address, and by trying to force these two diametrically-opposed ideas together, what resulted was neither a successful homage to soap operas nor a clever and relatable exploration of themes of loss and grief. And frankly, that should have been obvious to all involved well before the episode even had a finished script.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing La'an with fake Sybok
La’an with Sybok. Sorry: “Sybok.”

Uhura’s story, seeing Pike as her father (for inexplicable reasons) was little more than a piss-take of similar soap opera plots over the years. And I mean… I get it. Two totally unrelated characters, who viewers have known for years, are suddenly revealed to be father and daughter or mother and son or long-lost conjoined twins. I get it. It’s a soap opera trope. But did it need to be such a big part of Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass? And what was the point of it for Uhura?

For Pike, this story tracks insofar as it set up his arc of confronting what happened to his family in the life he led and lost. But for Uhura… what are we supposed to get from this storyline? Am I missing something? She sees Pike as an important mentor figure in her life. Great. We knew that already. But given where Uhura is in her character journey – and the season’s stated aim of moving characters “one step closer to where it all began” – what are we gaining by putting her, of all people, into this soap opera plotline with Pike? I know it wasn’t real (and it was obviously not supposed to be real), but still. This was such a big part of the episode – and not just from Pike’s perspective – and yet we gained basically nothing from it.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike and Uhura
What was the point of this story for Uhura?

I’m not from the United States (and I’m not a viewer of American soaps), so I confess that I didn’t know who actress Deidre Hall was when she was introduced as Counsellor Eleanor Chivers. If you’re in the same boat as me, Hall has played one of the main characters on the American soap Days of Our Lives since 1976, so bringing her aboard for an episode with this soap opera style was a genuine coup for Strange New Worlds. If you’re British, like me, I guess this would be akin to bringing William Roache (Ken Barlow on Coronation Street) on board for a guest-starring role.

Outside of the soap opera pseudo-reality, we didn’t get to spend too much time with Chivers. I liked her outfit, which I felt drew a little on TNG’s Dr Crusher for inspiration, being a similar length and colour, but obviously a bit more elaborate with its collar and the way it fastened. And I think it’s interesting that, at least in this era, the Enterprise has a counsellor on board.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Chivers
Doctor (or Counsellor?) Chivers.

However, given last week’s (re)introduction of Dr Boyce – who, as the ship’s former chief medical officer, served as kind of unofficial counsellor to Captain Pike… well, bringing Counsellor Chivers into the mix as well might arguably complicate things. I thought, at first, we were going to learn that Chivers was one of Trelane’s creations, a fictional character he invented for the sake of his dramatic production. But Chivers is, apparently, a fixture aboard the Enterprise.

I think you could argue that it makes sense for Pike to seek out an *actual* counsellor, given where he’s at emotionally, instead of trying to talk to someone like Dr Boyce, Una, or Dr M’Benga, so it’s not necessarily a *bad* thing. And starships having counsellors is clearly not uncommon for Starfleet in this era; I think there was someone in that role aboard the USS Discovery, or at least I remember it being mentioned.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike and Chivers
Funnily enough, I had Pike’s expression on my face for almost the entire time I was watching Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass.

I would’ve definitely liked to have spent more time with Pike and Chivers outside of the soap opera sequences; Pike’s breakdown in her office had all of the ingredients to be the kind of hard-hitting moment that his storyline needed more of, and Anson Mount genuinely gave an exceptional performance in that scene. It was just cut too short for an episode that wanted to do other things.

Within the soap opera reality, though, I don’t really know what to say. Chivers was – surprisingly, perhaps – the least-offensive of the soap opera fluff. Deidre Hall wasn’t hamming it up in the way that most of the show’s regulars were, leaving her character to feel like simultaneously the most-grounded and least-likely to be real at the same time. An odd mix… but then again, that’s Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass in a nutshell, eh?

Behind-the-scenes photo from Star Trek SNW 4x07
Ethan Peck (left) and guest-star Rhys Darby on the set of Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass.

Season 1’s The Serene Squall reintroduced us to Spock’s half-brother, Sybok – albeit only briefly – and ever since, I think a lot of Trekkies have been wondering whether Sybok would be back before Strange New Worlds comes to the end of its run. And as I was saying above with Pike and La’an and their complex storylines… I would not have chosen to bring back “Sybok” in this form, if I had been in charge! In this case, though, that’s for a different reason.

Pike’s story (and La’an’s too, to a lesser extent) needed to be more grounded and serious if the messaging was going to stick the landing. But Sybok, because he’s such a uniquely interesting character within the broader lore and canon of Star Trek… well, I think he deserved to be handled better. Being reduced to essentially a joke; a gag parodying the “evil twin” cliché from bad soap opera storylines… I mean, I think even Sybok – who was a part of what is usually considered the weakest film, at least of The Original Series era – deserved better than that.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing fake Sybok
The illusory “Sybok”.

Moreover, there was a chance for Strange New Worlds to explore the feud between Sybok and Spock – and perhaps between Spock and his father, Sarek, too – in more detail than we ever got in TOS or The Final Frontier. If I were making a list of potential characters and stories to return to for a potential “Captain Pike show,” I’m not sure I’d necessarily have picked Sybok. But having teased the character back in Season 1, I can see the value in revisiting him, expanding on his backstory with Spock, and going into more depth about their conflict.

Such a storyline could have set up the events of The Final Frontier, or at least leaned into Sybok’s “share your pain” philosophy that would be so important to the events of that film. And I’m left lamenting, really, that Strange New Worlds took nothing but this character’s name to do a very silly (and far too long) gag or bit with it. Once again… what was the point?

Still frame from Star Trek V showing Sybok.
Sybok in The Final Frontier.

That last question – “what was the point?” – could really apply to 90% of the episode, to be honest. Previous genre parodies have (usually) made the case for themselves; even if I didn’t personally like the finished product, I could at least see what the writers and production team were going for. But in this case, I’m really struggling to see what the intention was in doing a soap opera spoof other than… to do a spoof.

And is *that* a good use of the show’s time when there are a mere nine episodes remaining, and fewer than fifty in total?

If this was Season 1 or 2, with Strange New Worlds potentially looking at a six-, seven-, or eight-season run, I still wouldn’t *like* this episode, but I think it might’ve felt less offensive. However, we’re now nine episodes from the show’s finale, and I just don’t think there was time to waste on a genre parody or spoof that not only didn’t have anything to say in and of itself, but that also ended up actively detracting from what should’ve been a powerful, emotional, and relatable arc for two of the show’s main characters.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Pike
Captain Pike.

With the exception of Anson Mount, who did well with Captain Pike’s emotional torment, the only other performer I could really single out for praise is Rhys Darby, who reprised his role as Trelane from Season 3’s Wedding Bell Blues. We’re sticking with the idea that Trelane is a kid, and Darby brought almost a sense of childlike wonder to the character, despite having phenomenal powers and abusing them to toy with the emotions of the crew.

I also found it interesting that Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass introduced another member of the Q Continuum as Trelane’s teacher/advisor. I wasn’t wild about the Q-inspired costuming, though: the judges’ robes that Q wore in The Next Generation were meant to be a copy of something from Earth in the mid/late 21st Century, and I felt that leaning on that idea for inspiration kind of misunderstands or muddles that. A very minor point, admittedly, and one that you might say is a nitpick. But I like Star Trek to be consistent with itself, and for me, this other Q wearing an outfit clearly at least partially inspired by those judges’ robes wasn’t right.

Oh, and if you missed it last season: yes, Rhys Darby’s character is the same Trelane as Kirk will encounter in The Original Series, and he’s a member of the Q Continuum. Spoiler alert for Wedding Bell Blues, I guess!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Trelane (post-credits)
Rhys Darby is great as Trelane.

There were a couple of funny moments in Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass that successfully won a chuckle, or at least made me smile. Dr M’Benga having a disease as ludicrously-named as “space madness” was one of them, because it was just so utterly absurd and silly.

And it was also a funny bit to see Trelane and his teacher munching on buckets of popcorn as they watched Captain Pike wrangling with the memory of his daughter; neither of them expected that “storyline” in Trelane’s fantasy world, I guess. It was a funny moment, in any case.

But that’s really all the praise I have for this… well, this disappointing mess.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Trelane and his Q mentor eating popcorn
This was an admittedly funny visual.

Do I need to tell you, for the fourth or fifth time this season, that I can respect the commitment to the bit; that fully and whole-heartedly embracing everything about a genre in this kind of genre parody is, in some ways, commendable? Because I feel like I’ve been saying that a lot, of late!

Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass is the first episode, really, where I feel that everyone involved should’ve known that the core concept and storylines wouldn’t work. The hammy over-acting, the ridiculous dialogue, and the attempt to blend a full-throated soap opera pastiche with complex themes and long-running storylines for main characters was a genuinely bad idea. And I’d actually quite like to know how this concept made it all the way through the production process. How is it that no one – not one single person from this pretty accomplished group of television writers and producers – didn’t stop for a second and say, “yeah, this ain’t gonna work”?

Behind-the-scenes photo from Star Trek SNW 4x07
Cast and crew behind-the-scenes.

Like Chonitons Through the Hourglass is saved from the title of “worst Strange New Worlds episode” by the existence of Subspace Rhapsody and the “but it was all just a dream” ending to Level-Five Transporter Accident. But that’s it. That’s the best I can say about it… and I guess that makes it the third-worst episode of the series.

Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass isn’t just a disappointment because its soap opera parody was over-the-top, hammy, and silly. Those things made me roll my eyes, sure, but as someone who isn’t a soap fan, perhaps that side of the story would never have been “my thing,” and that’s okay. Not every episode is gonna be a ten-out-of-ten for every viewer, especially with such narrative and genre diversity on display. But because the episode’s other side had an important and potentially powerful and emotional message about grief and loss… the failures of the soap opera fluff feel infinitely worse.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x07 showing Una and M'Benga
Dr M’Benga and Una.

I would’ve been down for an episode exploring Pike’s grief, either through a sci-fi lens or just… by playing it straight. And I liked the attempt to draw a comparison between Pike’s grief and La’an’s feelings about her second heartbreak. But those ideas got precious little time and attention in an episode that wanted to be something else – something fundamentally incompatible with those loftier ideas. The choice should’ve been to either massively reduce the soap stuff to a few small vignettes, drop it entirely, or else abandon the serious themes and lean fully into the parody.

I know what I’d have chosen, if I had the option.

Star Trek’s sixtieth anniversary is in just a few days’ time, and we’re going into the anniversary with *this* as the most recent episode. That… would not have been my preference, I’m not gonna lie. And now that Strange New Worlds Season 4 is three-quarters done, there are still only two episodes that I can say I fully enjoyed and didn’t find glaring flaws in. It’s such a shame that this show – which I’ve said repeatedly has been my favourite of Star Trek’s modern revival – just isn’t on top form at the moment.

Next week, we’re going to get Orders of Magnitude – an episode which promises “an alien pursuit that grows far beyond its original orders.” Maybe that’ll be a better, more grounded, or more interesting story. Maybe it’ll be *orders of magnitude* better than a soap opera parody or an episode that ends with “but it was all just a dream.” We can but hope, I suppose.

Thanks for joining me for this review. I really don’t like being so negative about Star Trek, and especially about Strange New Worlds when there are so few episodes remaining. But… here we are, I guess. I’m crossing my fingers and hoping for better things next time.

I’ll be writing something celebratory on the 8th for Star Trek’s official sixtieth anniversary, so I hope you’ll join me for that. And earlier in the year, I wrote up re-watches of Where No Man Has Gone Before, which was TOS’s second pilot, The Royale, which was my personal “first contact” with the franchise, and a few other pieces, too, like my encounter with William Shatner, some “what-if” scenarios, and some fascinating fan theories that I found! I’ve also reviewed Season 1 of Starfleet Academy and the video game Across The Unknown, which is based on Star Trek: Voyager. I hope you’ll check out some of those pieces if you have the time. You can also find the rest of my Strange New Worlds reviews by clicking or tapping here. As always… Live Long and Prosper, friends!


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4 are available to stream now on Paramount+ in countries and territories where the platform is available. The first three seasons are also available on DVD and/or Blu-ray. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds and all other properties discussed above – is the copyright of the Skydance-Paramount corporation. Days of Our Lives is the copyright of NBC/Corday Productions/Peacock. This review contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Episode Review – Season 4, Episode 4: A Case of Chiaroscuro

A Star Trek-themed spoiler warning (black and white)

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: The Original Series, The Search for Spock, The Next Generation, Deep Space Nine, Enterprise, and Lower Decks.

I think I ought to start this week’s review with a bit of an explanation of how I try to approach new episodes of Star Trek. On the one hand, I’m obviously going to tell you whether I personally enjoyed the story, the character moments, the presentation, the score… all of that *subjective* stuff. But I also try to keep in mind, when writing a review, what an episode was aiming for and how well it measured up to those objectives.

That’s why I can look at an episode like last week’s Human Best Friend and say that I truly enjoyed its sense of humour, its pastiche of films like The Hangover, and its genuinely well-written character moments – and why, conversely, I’ll tell you that the otherwise outstanding horror offering The Griffin Incident came with a glaring narrative flaw. I’ll even admit – however begrudingly – that Season 2’s Subspace Rhapsody was competently made, musically solid, and even had some solid characterisation… even though I will literally never watch that absolute travesty ever again!

Stylised promo photo from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing a vintage television set
I considered doing all of the still frames like this… but don’t worry, I thought better of it!

Why did I start my review of A Case of Chiaroscuro with that explanation-come-caveat? Well, the truth is… I *really* don’t like watching black-and-white films and TV shows. I realise that’s a horrible generalisation, and there are some exceptions – Christmas films, like Miracle on 34th Street, for instance. But, generally speaking, I just struggle to get immersed in black-and-white media, and *modern* productions which deliberately use black-and-white – as A Case of Chiaroscuro does – almost universally feel gimmicky and silly to me.

Again, this is a *subjective, not objective* take – but I wanted to be up front about my bias here, because my general dislike of black-and-white has undoubtedly coloured (pun very much intended) my thoughts on A Case of Chiaroscuro.

A Case of Chiaroscuro was a faithful recreation of the kind of ’30s and ’40s noir movies that inspired it. Not only in terms of its use of black-and-white, but the entire episode’s visual style and presentation all drew from that source, as did its score. Narratively, A Case of Chiaroscuro also leaned heavily on noir and melodrama from a bygone era. And regardless of whether I *liked* that in a personal sense… I respect the commitment to the bit.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the shuttle
A shuttle in black-and-white.

However, more so than any other story so far this season – and really, any other story in Strange New Worlds, save, perhaps for Subspace Rhapsody – A Case of Chiaroscuro felt like “a bit.” Its noir inspiration was *so* omnipresent in everything from the set design and music to the soft-focus close-up shots and narrative melodrama that it feels less like an actual story within the Star Trek universe and more like a pulpy television serial. It was hard to take A Case of Chiaroscuro as seriously as I wanted to – because, by turning the dials all the way up and not just drawing inspiration from film noir but actively copying as many aspects of it as possible, the episode imported all of what I’d consider to be the genre’s flaws.

By choosing to employ an outdated kind of storytelling – not just the black-and-white, but a melodramatic narrative with over-the-top twists and turns and cardboard cut-out secondary characters who didn’t feel like real people – A Case of Chiaroscuro feels… vintage. But that isn’t a good thing in this case, if we’re talking about an episode of Star Trek that I want to watch and enjoy. Most of the episode didn’t just look dated, but it also *felt* out-of-date; TV serials and movies like this were past their prime even sixty years ago, when The Original Series was on the air. And while there absolutely are interesting points in A Case of Chiaroscuro that I can wholeheartedly say that I enjoyed… the final product is simply too gimmicky for my personal taste.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the collaborator
The collaborator.

I concede, though, that A Case of Chiaroscuro knows exactly what kind of story it wants to tell, and sets out to tell it earnestly and successfully. I can absolutely see this being considered a highlight of the season – and perhaps even of Star Trek as a whole – for Trekkies who have a fondness for these kinds of mystery-thriller noir stories. And, as I’ve said before, it’s to the credit of the former Paramount corporation that the executives were willing to greenlight a project like this, to spend a not insignificant amount of money on scripts and sets, and to – for lack of a better word – allow Star Trek to be “weird.” I can’t think of many other big-budget streaming productions that would’ve so wholeheartedly embraced the kind of genre-shifting that Strange New Worlds has done… and, for all of the many, many flaws and failings of the old Paramount, I think they deserve at least some kudos for giving the thumbs-up to a story like this one.

So… another “big swing” in Season 4, then! Adventure, horror, comedy, and now film noir… and we still have the puppet episode yet to come. I think this season will go down in the history books for just how many different ideas the writers brought to the table – and I can appreciate the diversity, the semi-episodic storytelling, and the willingness to go to places Star Trek hasn’t always gone before. Even if the results, on this occasion, weren’t “my thing.”

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the city from above
The city on Mat’Aar XII.

Let’s concentrate on the part of the episode which I liked… or at least the part I felt wasn’t as weak as the main story.

Back aboard the Enterprise – but still in black-and-white – we have La’an’s investigation of a mysterious signal. The probe – little more than a macguffin to kick-start the episode’s two main storylines – may have been tampered with, or at least La’an believed so.

I liked the way that the episode framed this, and the way the story convinced us as the audience that what we were seeing was nothing more than La’an overreacting. Even the little recap at the beginning of the episode, which went back to last season, showed how La’an might be succumbing to paranoia. And, as her storyline unfolded, A Case of Chiaroscuro tried very hard to convey to us that La’an was seeing things that weren’t really there.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing La'an's padd
La’an investigated some missing data.

This made the ultimate reveal – that the probe *had* in fact been meddled with – hit a bit harder. I still don’t think that this storyline was executed perfectly; both Spock’s dismissal of La’an’s concerns and Chapel’s confession felt rushed. But that’s a consequence of this being the B-plot of an episode that had its attention elsewhere. Had we not already got a major La’an storyline already this season, I might’ve said I’d have liked to see this B-plot fleshed out into its own episode. But, that limitation aside, I liked this storyline.

Firstly, the Vulcan cadet – I’ve now learned her name is A’sha – finally got something plot-relevant to do after her introduction in the season premiere. Maybe it’s this episode’s noir tone and double- and triple-crosses, but I can’t help but wonder if A’sha is going to turn out to be a spy or something! But maybe that’s too much of a reach based on her limited screen time. In any case, it was nice to see her on the bridge and for her to get something to do. Modern Star Trek hasn’t always handled its secondary characters especially well, but it’s nice to get *some* conversations and interactions outside of the main cast; it populates the Enterprise and makes the broader world of Star Trek feel more lived-in and real.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing La'an and A'sha
La’an with Cadet A’Sha.

I wasn’t wild about the speed with which Spock dismissed La’an’s concerns – though, in a noir-style story, it made me question whether *he* might’ve been complicit in… whatever may or may not have been going on, so I guess that’s not all bad. I do wonder, though, what recent events – including last week’s argument in the bar and now this dismissive reaction – might mean for La’an’s relationship with Spock.

We also got a bit of a follow-up to last week’s episode as Ortegas and Scotty were seen hanging out together. I wondered, when they seemed to be in the same quarters, whether this might be another hint at some kind of romantic relationship, but La’an stated they’re “friends now,” at the end of the episode – and I think that’s how we’re meant to read it. In any case, it was cute to see them together after their adventure, and I appreciate how Strange New Worlds retains these character relationships and moments that it develops.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Scotty and Ortegas
Scotty and Ortegas are friends now, after last week’s adventure.

Scotty gave us a great line of technobabble about how he was keeping tabs on the Klingon ship, and that was both fun and very “Star Trekky,” for want of another term. I felt Dr M’Benga’s line about why everything was in black-and-white was a bit hand-wavey earlier in the episode, as technobabble goes, but Scotty’s was definitely more in line with what we’ve seen before. Not sure why he was keeping it a secret from the ship’s security officer, of all people, but I guess it worked as an excuse for La’an to chase leads and catch up with other members of the crew.

One thing I didn’t really like, though, was Scotty’s line about being “trapped in a transporter buffer;” a reference to his ultimate fate and the TNG episode Relics. If this had been a one-off, I wouldn’t have minded (I think), but so far this season, La’an has called back to The Search for Spock and Dr M’Benga made another reference to Relics just last week. Occasional callbacks to past iterations of Star Trek – or calls forward, I guess, to these characters’ fates and ultimate destinations – are okay, but they really ought to be *occasional*. Otherwise they come across as heavy-handed and overwhelming… and it just isn’t necessary and stops being fun. A single line like this is great; a nod and wink to long-time Trekkies. Too many just feel like navel-gazing, self-referential fluff… or just a plain lack of originality, I guess. And because we’ve had several of these lines in earlier episodes – one of which already featured Scotty – this one was a bridge too far. On its own? Totally okay. But after seeing several others already this season, I felt it crossed that invisible line between being a playful in-joke and becoming excessive.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Scotty
Don’t call it “foreshadowing”…

The conclusion of this storyline sees Chapel confessing to being the one who interfered with the probe and deleted its data. Though, as I said, this felt kind of rushed, it was nice that in this kind of storyline, the ending was difficult to deduce and there was still time for a twist. I think both Chapel and La’an got good moments of characterisation here: Chapel didn’t just let La’an think paranoia was overtaking her, instead confessing even though doing so could’ve had real consequences for her, and La’an chose loyalty to a friend over following the letter of the law.

For both characters, those are positive things – and while not “out of character” by any stretch, it’s still good to see both of them doing the right thing and choosing friendship, not blind rule-following. Chapel’s decision to delete the incriminating data felt understandable, even though I wish we’d gotten a longer scene explaining it, and La’an’s choice to keep the issue between them said a lot about her character. If, as I’ve theorised, we could be seeing the beginning of the end for La’an – either aboard the Enterprise or, y’know, alive – moments like this will be all the more important.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing La'an and Chapel
Nurse Chapel with La’an in Sickbay.

La’an got this week’s secondary story, with the main focus of A Case of Chiaroscuro being on Una. But these two stories were thematically linked, and that made these two otherwise disconnected parts of the episode feel a bit closer together. La’an had to wrangle with her own paranoia and consider whether she was imagining things, or whether there actually was an issue with the probe. But the end of this story saw her choosing to do the right thing by a friend, even if that ment bending the rules.

Una’s story ends in a similar way. She chooses to bend the rules – in this case actively, whereas La’an’s was more passive, I suppose – to facilitate the rebels’ plan on Mat’Aar XII. But both characters had to deal with intrigue, mysteries, and ultimately, both had to decide whether to do the right thing – or what the “right” thing even is when faced with complex and nuanced situations.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Una and M'Benga
Una’s storyline was similar, in thematic terms, to La’an’s.

Before we get further into the main thrust of the mysteries on Mat’Aar XII, I want to talk briefly about the Klingons.

A Case of Chiaroscuro wasn’t really a Klingon episode. The Klingons were present, sure, and they played a significant narrative role – but the bulk of the story was focused on the main characters and the intrigue on Mat’Aar XII. But the episode did something for the Klingons that I think is kind of important – and that I approve of!

I’ve said, on the record, that I felt Enterprise’s “Klingon-augment virus” storyline was one of the show’s weakest, and that the change in prosthetic makeup for the Klingons in between TOS and The Motion Picture simply did not need to be called attention to nor given an in-universe explanation. Thankfully, modern Star Trek has walked away from that idea, and we’ve already seen Klingons in Strange New Worlds with the more familiar design. That continued here – even with the character of Kor. Kor is a Klingon who tangled with Kirk in The Original Series and returned in three episodes of Deep Space Nine, too.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Kor and three Klingons
Kor with his band of Klingons.

In Kor’s TOS and TAS appearances, he sports the original Klingon aesthetic, but this was updated for DS9. So if you want to be fussy about it, now we have a contradiction! But I don’t really see it as a contradiction at all. Just as when Kor appeared in DS9, prosthetic forehead and all, Star Trek was kind of drawing a line under TOS and updating things without drawing attention to it. And I read this prequel version of Kor in much the same way. Some parts of Star Trek… well, they can (and should) be ignored. Some stories didn’t work, some aesthetic changes could be made as new technologies and higher budgets allowed, and this is the result.

And hey, if you want to be picky and make everything in Star Trek fit? Let’s just say that Kor contracted the virus in between his posting to Mat’Aar XII and his run-in with Kirk!

I felt that Demore Barnes’ take on the character of Kor was one of the best parts of this weaker side of the story. Barnes – who you might recognise from Supernatural, Hannibal, or Twelve Monkeys, among other high-profile TV roles – was absolutely excellent in this villainous role, showing us a nuanced take on a Klingon leader that didn’t just rely on anger, aggression, and murder. In this kind of noir-inspired story, that’s how a villain should behave. Was bringing Kor into the show a bit of cheap nostalgia bait for Trekkies? Well… maybe. And I could entertain the argument that *this* version of Kor doesn’t fully line up with the way the character behaved in TOS and DS9. But that doesn’t mean I didn’t enjoy the performance or Kor’s role in the story!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Kor
I enjoyed this new take on the established character of Kor.

The Klingons, in their original incarnation some sixty years ago, were famously meant to be metaphorical stand-ins for the Soviet Union, with the Federation representing the United States or the broader western alliance. And A Case of Chiaroscuro called attention to the “cold war” that exists between the Klingons and Federation in this time period. That little connection was neat, and the lines referring to it were well-delivered.

But in this story, the Klingons felt less like 1960s Soviets and more like 1940s Nazis with the way their occupation of Mat’Aar XII came to life. Roving gangs of collaborators, uniformed soldiers, symbolic armbands, and propaganda messages being broadcast all linked up to create a really unsettling feel to the entire city; even seemingly “safe” spaces like the bar or the office felt like they could be raided or interfered with at any moment.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Una in her doppelgänger's office
Una in the doppelgänger’s office.

The sets and stages used to create Mat’Aar XII were genuinely very well done. I got a “Paris in World War II” kind of vibe; that this city was very much under occupation. The ’40s-style barrage balloons, the spotlights, and the art deco-style architecture (which was mostly seen in CGI establishing shots) all added to this sensation, as did the claustrophobic street set with its archway checkpoint. The white steam or smoke – another hallmark of films from this era – was well-used, too. As I said above, every aspect of A Case of Chiaroscuro leaned into this film noir style, and that extends to the way the sets were designed. The city was undeniably atmospheric.

Parts of A Case of Chiaroscuro reminded me a little of A Piece of the Action from TOS – the “gangster episode” where Kirk and co. visit a planet whose inhabitants were inspired by a book about 1920s Chicago. Some of the costumes, sets, and vehicles – all inspired by the first half of the 20th Century – gave me that feeling, and even the Klingons’ disruptors seemed to resemble Tommy guns! Obviously, A Piece of the Action was, itself, drawing on stories from the ’30s and ’40s for inspiration – G-Men, Invisible Stripes, and others – and there’s a difference between the kind of noir story present here and the simplified gangster/crime drama of that older episode. But, as I’ve said before, it can be nice when Star Trek stories… rhyme.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the city on Mat'Aar XII
I liked these establishing shots of the city, and how atmospheric they felt.

The main storyline’s central conceit was that Una is the exact doppelgänger of Mat’Aar XII’s resistance leader. And… I gotta be honest: I hated this and the stupid way it was “explained.” Basically, Dr M’Benga says that “well, space is big so we all have doppelgängers,” and that hand-wavey line is the only explanation offered for this really contrived setup. I admit that I don’t see an easy narrative pathway to tell this exact story without having Una share the exact same look as the resistance leader, but the way it was handled left a lot to be desired.

As I said in my review of The Griffin Incident: this is Star Trek. And in Star Trek, we like our technobabble explanations! You don’t have to be 100% scientifically accurate. You can make something up and then invent fancy-sounding technical words to fit. But in Star Trek stories, I don’t think it’s too much to ask that major narrative points receive more of an explanation than we got in A Case of Chiaroscuro. It was just a weaker narrative setup than the story deserved.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the doppelgänger's corpse
The doppelgänger’s corpse.

Once you got that out of the way, though, A Case of Chiaroscuro was a good episode for Una’s character journey. Her story intersected with her Illyrian heritage – something that we learned about in Season 2 – and gave her an arc about “doing the right thing” even if that meant breaking the rules. For a character who’s usually portrayed as a by-the-book kind of officer, this was a turn – albeit one that makes sense in context.

One thing I didn’t really follow, on this side of the story, was whether the Prime Directive should’ve been applied to Mat’Aar XII and its inhabitants. The planet’s own technology looked like it was from the 20th Century, with only the Klingons in possession of what might reasonably look like 23rd Century tech. But, despite being undercover the entire time, none of the away team mentioned the Prime Directive even once. Does it cease to apply when a planet meets another interstellar power, maybe?

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Una and Dr M'Benga with the bartender
So I guess the Prime Directive doesn’t apply…

To get back to Una, there was a lot of noir-style intrigue on this side of the story, as Una’s doppelgänger appeared, at first, to be a collaborator, then a rebel leader, and the episode did a reasonably good job of making it difficult to know who she could fully trust. Most of the Mat’Aar XII inhabitants felt fairly two-dimensional – which, let’s be honest, is kind of a hallmark of many films of the era A Case of Chiaroscuro is mimicking – but the question of which one of them betrayed Una’s doppelgänger still felt like an open one as the story progressed.

One thing I don’t really like in Star Trek – and *especially* in modern Star Trek – is just how many alien races are literally identical to humans! There aren’t enough “alien-looking” aliens in Star Trek’s galaxy, and while this was a contrivance during the early days of The Original Series with all of its budgetary and technical limitations… it’s something I wish modern Star Trek would dump. On this occasion, given that Una needed to be an exact lookalike of this rebel leader, I guess you can say the story wouldn’t have worked. But the episode itself even referenced this, with Uhura wondering aloud what the native population of Mat’Aar XII look like. It’s just something that, in older shows – and TOS in particular – I could overlook, but I don’t think it really fits modern Star Trek or a modern sci-fi setting any more, and I’d rather see the franchise invent more aliens who look truly otherworldly and different. With a few changes, we could’ve said that Mat’Aar XII was a human colony under occupation, or… something.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Mat'Aar-ians
Mat’Aar-ians.

That issue also extends into Uhura’s storyline. After being arrested by the Klingons for not showing her ID, Uhura was taken to a Klingon facility to be tortured. But despite having access to 23rd Century scanners, tricorders, and some kind of brain-alyser, the Klingons never found out that she wasn’t actually a Mat’Aar-ian. How’s that possible? Even human-looking aliens, surely, have different DNA or other identifying markers? That’s how sensors and tricorders across Star Trek are able to differentiate between different races.

As an aside, though, I actually really liked the design of the Klingon torture device. It was a retro throwback – and, in this case, I mean that as a positive thing! I suspect that, if the episode was in full colour and trying to employ a more modern visual style, something like that would’ve looked dated and out-of-place, but in this kind of story, the brain-alyser looked pitch-perfect! There’s something about its simple design that just felt like the perfect TOS throwback, and it looked great.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the torture machine/brain-alyser
The brain-alyser.

To wrap up Una’s story, I thought the ending was pretty predictable; I clocked what Una had done – planting the macguffin bomb thing on the collaborator – long before the episode revealed it. But at the same time, it says something about her character that she’d get so involved in this planet’s cause and crusade for freedom. Una bent (or broke) the rules in order to help the people of Mat’Aar XII in their fight against the Klingon occupation, despite knowing that doing so could have massive consequences. She took a risk, but it always felt like a calculated risk.

Dr M’Benga referenced his service in the Klingon War – something that’s become a defining trait of his character, especially in more recent seasons. The show’s writers clearly like this idea of “the doctor who’s also a special forces killer,” and they’ve really latched onto that. I would like to see Dr M’Benga in different storylines, though, as I feel his arc with the Klingons and his backstory from his war days has been reasonably well explored, and with limited time remaining to do anything else… well, time’s a-ticking, sadly.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing M'Benga
Dr M’Benga.

That being said, Dr M’Benga was a great choice to involve in a story like this, not least because of the Klingon element. He managed to be a mentor to both Una and Uhura at different points, offering advice, making note of how the Mat’Aar XII resistance was operating, and kind of serving as an exposition device for us as the audience, too! His war service felt like a natural thing for him to bring up in the context of the story, and while there were some contrivances – like how he could instantly recognise Kor, for example – they’re minor enough to not be bothersome.

Dr M’Benga guided Una, keeping her from making too many mistakes, but this was still Una’s story first and foremost, so we didn’t get any gratuitous scenes of him massacring legions of Klingons, or using his special forces background as an excuse to take the lead. Again, given the kind of story this was, and who it was centred around, that worked pretty well. From an in-universe standpoint, Dr M’Benga has told us many times that he wants to leave his past behind him, so again, his taking a back seat makes sense, too.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Uhura and M'Benga
Uhura and Dr M’Benga.

Celia Rose Gooding put in a great performance as Uhura this week. This younger version of the character is still, in some ways, finding her feet – and this mission took her far outside her comfort zone in more ways than one. Uhura’s friendship with Dr M’Benga was on full display, and the two characters played off one another exceptionally well in those supporting roles for Una and the noir-intrigue story.

However, I didn’t really feel like Uhura was ever in any real *danger,* even when she was literally facing the Klingons and their torture machine. Partly this is because Strange New Worlds is a prequel, and we know, in the backs of our minds, that Uhura will make it off-planet, back to Starfleet, and resume her career (relatively) unscathed. However, for a storyline involving literal torture… I think the episode could’ve made more of it. Perhaps Uhura will reference this experience in a future episode; I didn’t get the feeling, though, that this was an “Ortegas with the Gorn” or a “La’an’s DNA” type of situation, where a character’s storyline in one episode is clearly being set up for something more. But I guess we’ll have to wait and see on that front!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Uhura being tortured by the brain-alyser
Will this storyline lead to anything more for Uhura?

A couple of final points before we wrap things up.

This is at least the second Strange New Worlds episode where ships (or a shuttle, in this case) have literally been within visual range of one another, but – for no other reason I can discern than “because plot” – the adversary’s ship doesn’t notice or detect our heroes. In this case, a Klingon battlecruiser just wasn’t aware of either the probe or the shuttlecraft until the shuttle passed through the planet’s sensor grid. I know that, in prior Star Trek stories, the range at which sensors are effective can vary a lot depending on the needs of the story… but even with that in mind, this feels like a real stretch.

For the third episode in a row, Captain Pike had very little to do. I think I said this last season, too, but one of the main appeals of “the Captain Pike show” that fans – myself included – were clamouring for back in 2019 was Anson Mount and his incredible take on this character. We’re now a mere twelve episodes away from the end of the show’s run… and I kind of want to get a few more stories with Pike before the curtain falls. Star Trek has always done spotlight episodes where one or two characters are in focus – and this episode was very much an Una story, with supporting roles for Uhura and M’Benga, and a B-plot for La’an. And that’s great! But with limited time remaining, I’d like to spend a bit more time with the Enterprise’s captain.

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing Pike
Captain Pike hasn’t had much to do for several episodes now.

As the dust settles, I’m left with one feeling more than any other: A Case of Chiaroscuro just isn’t an episode I’m in a rush to revisit, and as and when I return to Strange New Worlds in the future, it’s an episode I’m more likely to skip than sit through. Despite its earnestness and the way it fully embraced its film noir and mystery inspirations… it just wasn’t for me. Partly that’s the black-and-white; a gimmick that felt, well… nothing more than gimmicky. But it’s also, at least in part, due to some outdated and two-dimensional tropes among the secondary characters, the melodrama that the episode imports directly from its source material, and the simple fact that this genre is quite a niche thing nowadays.

That being said, I tried very hard to give A Case of Chiaroscuro a fair shake, and not pre-judge it based solely on the fact that it was going to be in black-and-white. And, as I said above, I respect both Strange New Worlds’ creative team and the leaders at Paramount for creating a story like this and getting it across the line in a way that stayed largely true to the kinds of stories that inspired it. It’s something very few other franchises would attempt, and – at least in that sense – it’s a very “Star Trekky” thing!

Still frame from Star Trek SNW 4x04 showing the yard set with vehicles
A Case of Chiaroscuro stayed true to its noir inspirations.

Next week, Strange New Worlds is going to serve up a Level-Five Transporter Accident – the (in)famous “puppet episode” that was teased in pre-season marketing. I honestly don’t know what to expect from that one; I like that they went to the Jim Henson Company to get proper puppets made, and there’s a potential tie-in, I guess, with an episode of Lower Decks that could be interesting. It’s certainly going to be another “big swing” after this week’s noir-style story.

I hope this has been interesting! As I often say: please keep in mind that all of this is just the *subjective, not objective* take of one old Trekkie. If you liked A Case of Chiaroscuro a lot more than I did, feel it’s irredeemably awful, or just don’t agree with my take… that’s okay! There’s plenty of room in the Star Trek fan community for differences of opinion and respectful disagreement.

Thanks for joining me for this review, and as always… Live Long and Prosper, friends!


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-4 are available to stream now on Paramount+ in countries and territories where the platform is available. The first three seasons are also available on DVD and/or Blu-ray. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds and all other properties discussed above – is the copyright of the Skydance-Paramount corporation. This review contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.

Strange New Worlds: Taking Stock

A Strange New Worlds-themed spoiler warning.

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-3. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: The Original Series, Deep Space Nine, Discovery, and Picard.

At time of writing, Season 3 of Strange New Worlds has just concluded. With Starfleet Academy on the schedule for the first half of next year, and with Season 4 having only finished filming a few weeks ago, there’s gonna be a wait of a year-plus before we’ll see it – late 2026 or early 2027 is my guess, barring any strikes or similar disruptions! So it’s a bit early to look ahead – but Strange New Worlds is on my mind right now.

What I want to do this time is try to take stock of how the series has performed so far, as well as look ahead to a few things that I’d like to see in Seasons 4 and/or 5. This isn’t going to be a review or a recap of Season 3, though obviously we’ll talk about Season 3 along the way, but rather a broader overview of how I see Strange New Worlds now that we’re three seasons in – and, regrettably, past the halfway point of what will be a forty-six-episode run.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing the Enterprise at warp.
The final shot of Season 3.

As always, a couple of caveats before we get much further. Firstly, I have no “insider information,” so anything I say about possible future episodes and stories should be viewed through that lens! And secondly, all of this is the subjective, not objective, opinion of one old Trekkie. If you disagree with me about Strange New Worlds, hate my take, or want to see the series go in a completely different direction… that’s okay! There’s enough room in the Star Trek fan community for differences of opinion and polite disagreement.

Alright, now that that’s out of the way… let’s talk Strange New Worlds!

Season 3 was, on the whole, pretty good. There were a couple of dud episodes, but even those had some redeeming qualities. It felt a bit more serialised this time, thanks to the ongoing Batel-Gorn storyline, but still episodic enough that we got a diverse mix of stories. If I had to highlight two episodes for special praise, I’d pick Through the Lens of Time and Terrarium. I think Through the Lens of Time is, with the benefit of hindsight, perhaps somewhat let down by a weaker conclusion in the season finale, but on its own it’s still a solid episode. And Terrarium is just fantastic across the board.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing Ortegas on an away mission.
Ortegas in Terrarium.

In terms of characters, I’d like to see Strange New Worlds do more with some of its original creations, rather than leaning so heavily on the younger versions of TOS characters. Scotty seems to have taken precedence over Pelia for a lot of engineering storylines, such as in A Space Adventure Hour, and because Pelia is just a ton of fun… that doesn’t sit right. She’s the chief engineer, and he’s… what? A glorified assistant at best. And although sometimes lacking in confidence, this version of Scotty is still working engineering miracles. We’ve seen that before, and while there’s definitely fun to be had in seeing Scotty’s growth and the development of some of his friendships with folks like Uhura and Kirk… I don’t want that to overwhelm an original character like Pelia.

I’ve said this before, but if Star Trek had relied so heavily on legacy characters when considering spin-offs in the 1980s and 1990s, the franchise would feel a lot smaller today. We might never have met the likes of Picard, Sisko, or Janeway if the folks in charge had insisted on retaining characters from past iterations of Star Trek – and I’m just a little concerned that the attention dedicated to legacy characters is beginning to overshadow the rest of the cast. Spock was almost omnipresent this season, and we got stories heavily focused on Kirk, Chapel, Scotty, and Uhura, too. I’m glad that we finally got an Ortegas episode – and that it was so darn good! But with only sixteen episodes remaining, I’d really like to see Strange New Worlds strike more of a balance between characters who’ll go on to play big roles in TOS and the rest of the cast.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing Kirk in the captain's chair of the Farragut.
Kirk in command.

I mentioned this in one of my Season 3 episode reviews, but La’an being related to iconic Star Trek villain Khan has been a complete nothing-burger so far, and unless something major changes on that front… I’m gonna reach the end of the series wishing she’d been given a different last name. If you know me, you know I’m not a stickler for the tiniest minutiae of “canon,” but given how important Khan is to Kirk, Spock, and really to Star Trek as a whole… making La’an a direct relative of Khan kind of treads on the toes of what was established in Space Seed. If there’d been a big narrative payoff for that, it could’ve easily been worth it. But so far? I’m afraid it hasn’t been.

Think about it like this: what would change about La’an if her last name had been… Shellac-Wombat instead of Noonien-Singh? She could still have been a descendant of augments. She could still have survived the Gorn as a kid. She could still have felt shame about her ancestry. She could still have developed a friendship with Una, fallen for Kirk, and gotten into bed with Spock. Her iconic ancestor doesn’t matter one iota – and because of how important Khan still is to the franchise, I don’t think that’s good enough. There’s just no reason to have made her a member of Khan’s family – and right now, the name feels like little more than cheap nostalgia bait.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing La'an peeking out from a hiding place.
La’an in Season 2.

What appealed to me the most about “the Captain Pike show” in the aftermath of Discovery’s second season was spending more time with Anson Mount’s take on the character. Season 1 gave us a decent mix of Pike and other characters, but the captain seems to have stepped out of the limelight a little in Seasons 2 and 3. There were whole episodes this season where Pike got remarkably little to do, and one of his bigger roles – in Four-and-a-Half Vulcans – was far from his best. Anson Mount did a great job, by the way, in that kind of comedic role… but I just wasn’t thrilled about the end product.

So in Seasons 4 and 5, I hope we get to see a bit more of Pike. That doesn’t mean every story needs to put the captain front-and-centre, but there have been moments in some episodes which could’ve been perfect for Pike to step up and play a role – but where writing decisions meant other characters came to the fore. Maybe you think this contradicts my earlier wish to see more of Strange New Worlds’ original creations – but I kind of include Pike, Una, and Dr M’Benga along with the brand-new characters, as their roles prior to this series were much smaller.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing Pike holding a wine glass.
It’s still “the Captain Pike show” to me!

There are plenty of great characters on the show, and with only sixteen episodes left – and presumably at least one or two new recurring or secondary characters to be added – there are clearly gonna be constraints on how often Pike can be centre-stage… and I get that. But this is, for me, still “the Captain Pike show,” so when Pike is absent, relegated to a background role, or even mischaracterised – as I’d argue he was, to an extent, in episodes like Under the Cloak of War and Four-and-a-Half Vulcans – then a big part of Strange New Worlds is missing.

This leads into one of the concerns I have going into the remainder of the series: filming for Season 4 has already concluded, and Season 5 is currently underway. There’s no time for Skydance/Paramount to address feedback from Season 3; it’s too late to make any changes to the stories that have already been created. And given that Season 3 did have a couple of misfires and, I would argue, an over-use of characters like Kirk and Spock at the expense of Pike and some of Strange New Worlds’ original characters… that could be a problem. Feedback is important, especially in the modern streaming television landscape, and unfortunately, Strange New Worlds went ahead with producing Season 4 and 5 before there was a chance for any significant responses to Season 3 to be known. Hopefully, because the show is still pretty good, that won’t be too much of a problem. But I worry that the creative team may have doubled-down on some of the things that fans and viewers have been less keen on this time around.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing the Enterprise bridge.
Pike and the crew on the bridge.

Returning to Pike, I don’t think we need to see his accident and disability again at the end of the show. That story has already been told in Discovery, in The Original Series, and in a couple of Strange New Worlds episodes, so ending the show that way would, I would argue, be repetitive. If Kirk hadn’t been such a big presence this season, I’d probably have said that the series finale should show Pike handing over the Enterprise to Kirk – and a big part of me still believes that will be the final shot of the series. But given Kirk’s expanded role… I think some of the impact of that will be lost, even if the moment itself is handled well.

Instead, I think Strange New Worlds needs its very own Undiscovered Country-type of story. Perhaps Pike and the crew get word that the Enterprise is to undergo a major refit, and that Pike himself is to be promoted. The crew have one final mission to undertake – perhaps against the Klingons, the Gorn, or another well-known antagonist. The mission could be intense, explosive, and action-packed, but rather than the final moments of the show depicting the handover to Kirk… I’d like to see Pike on the bridge, setting course for parts unknown one final time.

Cropped comic book cover from the Star Trek: Strange New Worlds spin off series.
Ortegas, Una, Chapel, and Spock from one of the Strange New Worlds comic books.

We’ve had it confirmed in a recent interview that the creative team weren’t sure a renewal was coming after Season 3, which I think explains a few major decisions this time around. It explains why there was such a rush to do the “backdoor pilot” for their Year One idea, with Kirk, Spock, Scotty, Chapel, and Uhura all working together. It explains why some characters – like Chapel and Uhura – now feel like they’re coming to the ends of their arcs on the show. And it explains that epilogue in the season finale, which I said in my review felt like it was intended to serve as the ultimate ending to the show if it hadn’t been picked up for more episodes.

Some of those decisions could, if the creative team are aware of them, open up different possibilities in Seasons 4 and 5. We’ve already had the “Kirk in command” Year One spin-off episode. So check that one off the list – no need to do that again. Chapel’s relationship with Dr Korby has emerged, gone through a couple of bumps in the road, and gotten to a point where he doesn’t need to regularly reappear. Uhura’s grown in confidence and ability, taking her from a raw cadet unsure of her place in Starfleet to a confident officer who was even willing to bend the rules. Spock has just been all over the place… but even if we never got another Spock episode, I think we can safely say we’ve spent more than enough time with him, too!

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing Spock.
Spock.

So that should open up other opportunities. We haven’t had a major storyline for Una since the beginning of Season 2 (and no, getting horny for Patton Oswalt doesn’t count). We finally got our Ortegas episode, three seasons in, but there’s still scope to do more with her character. It would be nice to get a story for Dr M’Benga that doesn’t revolve around either his violent past or some other secret he’s keeping from his shipmates – perhaps one that could explain why, by the time of The Original Series, he’s no longer the chief medical officer.

Then there’s the secondary cast. Mitchell’s been a regular on the bridge – maybe the show could do something with her? Admiral April’s family was hinted at in the Season 3 finale, as was his friendship with Pike, so perhaps a story in which he’s in focus would be well-received. I’d also love to get one more story featuring Hemmer! Perhaps a time-travel story, of some kind, could see Hemmer getting some screen time with Scotty? That could be absolutely fantastic if handled well. And Sam Kirk has been rather overshadowed by Spock in the science department and his brother, but it would be lovely to get a story in which he’s in focus, for once.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing Sam Kirk holding a machine.
Sam Kirk in Season 2.

You’ll have heard me say this before (I often use it as a bit of a caveat when talking about episodes I didn’t like!) but I’m really glad to see Strange New Worlds remaining a mostly episodic show. Discovery and Picard both went for big, season-long serialised arcs… but for me, that’s not really what I’ve wanted from Star Trek. In past shows, where seasons were longer and there was more room for manoeuvre, arcs like the Dominion War worked pretty well. But in the modern television landscape, where there are fewer episodes and fewer seasons available, I think Star Trek really needs the diversity and options that only an episodic format can deliver.

So, as production gets underway on Season 5… please keep the episodic format! A two-part or even three-part finale could work, sure, but I hope that at least some of Season 5 can retain the episodic charm that has made Strange New Worlds feel like such a nostalgic throwback in the best possible way. It wasn’t until I started watching Strange New Worlds that I came to recognise how much I’ve missed episodic television – and how essential the format is to a franchise like Star Trek.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing zombies.
The zombies in Shuttle to Kenfori.

Star Trek shows need the freedom to explore strange new worlds… pretty much every week. The Enterprise needs to visit a planet, meet an alien, then warp away to a different destination next time. As Strange New Worlds has demonstrated, that doesn’t mean you have to lose character growth, personal relationships, and other modern television trappings. But it means that, for a franchise all about exploring the galaxy, spending too long in one place or having too narrow a focus isn’t what works best. And I’m not alone in feeling that way, I suspect.

I think there’s room for something like a two-part finale to wrap up the show, or even a two-part cliffhanger in between Seasons 4 and 5, as we got with Seasons 2 and 3. One or both of those ideas could be great. But what I don’t want to see, really, is for Seasons 4 and 5 to go down the Discovery/Picard route of being fully serialised, as I think that would take away so much of what has made Strange New Worlds work. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that the Strange New Worlds model – which I’d describe as episodic with character arcs – should be adopted by Starfleet Academy and by any other Star Trek project that might get greenlit in the years ahead. It’s absolutely the best choice for this franchise.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing La'an on the holodeck.
La’an on the holodeck.

At this stage, with Starfleet Academy on the schedule for early 2026, I’m not convinced that Strange New Worlds’ fourth season will be ready in time for the 60th anniversary, which is now less than a year away! But if I could be allowed one “wish,” it would be for Season 4 to contain some kind of celebratory episode, perhaps a story akin to my Cardassia Prime pitch, which would bring in characters and factions from elsewhere in the franchise.

The 60th anniversary is an opportunity to celebrate a milestone that few franchises ever reach. And let’s be honest: with all the cancellations and Paramount+ struggling, being able to do anything big for the 70th or 75th seems unlikely! And speaking for myself… I might not be here by then! So I’d dearly love to see at least one Season 4 episode written as a “love letter” to Star Trek and to the fans, really leaning into the 60th anniversary and celebrating all things Star Trek.

Still frame from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds showing an illusion of Hemmer.
A 60th anniversary episode could really celebrate the franchise.

Before we wrap things up, I have a couple of much siller, almost-certain-never-to-be-made ideas. The first is one I’ve talked about a few times here on the website: rescuing Captain Lorca! Lorca appeared in Discovery’s first season, and the prime timeline version of the character is assumed to have died in the Mirror Universe… but what if he didn’t? Captain Pike could lead a rescue effort, stepping through the looking-glass to save a friend. I think that could be a ton of fun as an episode.

And finally… I still kinda want to see a “Captain Pike versus the Borg” story! Yes, there are timeline problems. Yes, it would tread on the toes of canon. And yes, the Borg have been overused in Picard in recent years. But still… I think you could write a script which sees Pike’s Enterprise catapulted to an alternate universe where the Borg are dominant, with Spock saying “it’s unlikely a cybernetic race like this exists in our universe,” and where La’an, Dr M’Benga, and the rest of the crew have to battle drones and figure out a way home. I just think it would be a really fun idea.

Still frame from Star Trek: First Contact showing a borg drone.
I know, I know… it ain’t gonna happen!

So that’s all for today!

We’ve talked about Strange New Worlds, the show’s first three seasons, some of its characters, and a few things I’d like to see going forward. I’m still disappointed that the show has been prematurely cancelled – especially because it happened before Season 3 had aired a single episode. But we are where we are, and there are now just sixteen episodes left. I’m keeping my fingers crossed for some wonderful adventures before Captain Pike and co. have to hang up their uniforms for the final time.

I hope this has been interesting. I wanted to talk about the show more broadly now that Season 3 has ended. I still don’t think we’re gonna see Season 4 before next autumn at the earliest – and a 2027 release doesn’t seem impossible, either, given the lengthy post-production involved for modern shows. So… it could be a while before we rejoin Pike, Spock, Una, and the rest of the crew. Before then, I’d like to finally write up some Season 1 episodes, which I didn’t do at the time because Paramount cut off Strange New Worlds from an international audience! And if and when there’s a trailer, a teaser, or more information revealed about the upcoming season, I daresay I’ll take a look. Until then… Live Long and Prosper!


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-3 are available to stream now on Paramount+ in countries and territories where the platform exists. The first two seasons are also available on DVD/Blu-ray. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds and all other properties discussed above – is the copyright of Skydance and/or Paramount. This review contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Episode Review – Season 2, Episode 3: Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow

Spoiler Warning: There are spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-2. Spoilers are also present for the following Star Trek productions: Picard Season 2, Enterprise, Voyager, and Deep Space Nine.

Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow was an interesting episode – and one of the better time travel stories in modern Star Trek. Its central pairing of La’an and an alternate timeline Kirk was interesting, and one that accomplished the objective of putting them together but without treading on the toes of established canon; Kirk’s legendary conflict with the original Khan Noonien Singh is something that modern Star Trek needs to preserve at all costs!

There were a few contrivances in the episode, though, and both the opening act and Kirk’s willingness to erase his own timeline seemed to be quite rushed. That’s despite Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow being the longest episode of the season so far!

Stranded in the past…

I’ve commented on this twice already this season, but here we go again: where oh where is Captain Pike?! Was Anson Mount unavailable for part of the season’s production? In the first episode, Pike was present only briefly before taking off on a mission of his own. Last week, the opening act saw Pike recruit Una’s lawyer – but he was then sidelined and didn’t have much to say. And this week, Pike got one line in a very short sequence right at the end of the episode. Is Paramount paying Anson Mount by the line these days? What’s going on?!

I say that jokingly – but Strange New Worlds was “the Captain Pike show” when we were campaigning to make it happen. You have to admit that it’s odd, at the very least, for Pike to have been so thoroughly absent in the first part of this season. Basically one-third of Season 2 has now progressed with very little input from the Enterprise’s captain. In past iterations of Star Trek there were always spotlight episodes for individuals and stories in which some characters were more prominent than others… but these came in longer seasons, and it was still relatively uncommon to go three episodes in a row with the captain having so little to do. In modern Star Trek it’s unprecedented; can you imagine if Discovery had run three episodes with so little screen time for Burnham? I just find the whole thing rather perplexing – even though I’ve enjoyed each of these three episodes.

Captain Pike was once again notable by his absence from the story.

Let’s talk about a specific story criticism. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow saw La’an make wild assumptions and leaps that had no basis in fact or logic. Given that she’s been thrust into a completely new and unfamiliar situation, her assumption that she must have been sent to a specific timeline to team up with Kirk, or to a specific moment in the past for a reason, or that the device she was given wouldn’t “unlock” until she’d completed her mission… all of these things and more needed more time to play out.

As much as I dislike Picard’s second season, the episode Penance is actually a reasonably good example of this “fish-out-of-water” idea. In that story, Picard and several of his crewmates find themselves in an alternate timeline, separated from one another and with no idea of what’s going on. It takes them basically an entire episode just to piece together what’s happened and get back together; it’s not something that can or should be rushed in the way that Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow tried to do.

La’an and Kirk made some wild leaps in logic.

We know that La’an is capable and self-reliant, but her completely baseless assumptions – though validated in a way by the resolution of the story – undermine her characterisation and significantly weaken the episode. Because of the time constraint, it was necessary for La’an to quickly assess the situation she found herself in and come up with a plan – but there may have been ways to cut some other scenes and sequences down, giving this incredibly important setup more time to play out.

This is also true, to an extent, of other parts of the episode. After seeing the bombing and chasing after stolen parts, La’an and Kirk seemed to pretty quickly figure out – again, via baseless assumption – what they had been sent to the past to do. Although Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow found time to slow down in between these rushed moments, the main plot of the episode seemed to leap from point to point incredibly quickly, leaving very little time to digest what was going on. I wanted to shout at La’an and Kirk to slow down and give me a moment to catch my breath!

Racing through the streets of Toronto…

While we’re picking holes in the story, I’ll say this: time travel can be exceptionally difficult to get right in any fictional setting. It’s all too easy to write oneself into a corner, relying on paradoxes, tropes, and “you can’t tell anyone this ever happened” in order to get out of it. The end of Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow raises such a point: if the Department of Temporal Investigations knew what was going on and were able to observe La’an and Kirk, why didn’t they intervene?

La’an is a 23rd Century security officer, and Kirk was a starship captain from a dystopian timeline that shouldn’t exist. They are categorically not the best-qualified people to stop a Romulan super-spy from the future… not without help or guidance, at any rate. If the episode had ended without the official from Temporal Investigations showing up, I guess we could have written it off as the first agent turning to La’an out of desperation. But knowing that this organisation had been watching her all along… it kind of smacks of Enterprise’s Temporal Agent Daniels teaming up with the 22nd Century’s Captain Archer. Surely these organisations have their own staff!

Doesn’t the Department of Temporal Investigations have its own staff?!

That being said, Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow might just be my favourite Star Trek time travel story – or at least my favourite one for a long while! Time travel to the modern day is difficult to get right, and practically every Star Trek episode that’s taken this approach has also taken its crew to the sunlit coast of southern California. This happened in Voyager, in Picard, and even in The Voyage Home. By taking the simple step of visiting Toronto (where the series is filmed) Strange New Worlds was already doing something different. I appreciated that.

I was worried that, coming only a year after Picard Season 2 had spent eight-and-a-half episodes wandering in the 21st Century, Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow might just turn me off before it even got started. Luckily that wasn’t the case, and we got a good mix of lighthearted moments. Kirk and La’an having to figure out how to dress and how to act in an unfamiliar environment stood in contrast to the heavier storyline involving time-travelling terrorists and a plot to stop the Federation from ever being created.

There were lighter moments to balance out a heavy story.

This last point – preventing the Federation from coming into existence – was a fascinating one that I would have loved to explore in more detail. Because it was only revealed at the climax of the plot that the Federation’s existence hinged upon disaster, genocide, and the reign of terror that Khan brought to Earth, there wasn’t an awful lot of time to get into the real implications of this – and of the decision that La’an was forced to make.

But this is such an interesting idea! I even wondered if Picard’s aforementioned second season might’ve been going for a similar setup, because the idea of having to consciously choose to permit something so horrific is a real moral quandary. In that moment, La’an was face-to-face with one of Earth’s most brutal dictators. She could have chosen to kill him, sparing Earth the torment that she knows is 100% guaranteed to happen. But she didn’t – she couldn’t. Not because she wanted it to happen, but because she knew that without those horrors, the future would be radically and almost unimaginably altered.

La’an confronted her family legacy.

The fact that La’an has a personal family tie here makes it an even more complex idea. La’an has spent her life living in the shadow of an infamous, hated ancestor – and she was given an opportunity to prevent any of that from ever happening. The themes at play here, expressed through La’an’s decision and the impossible choice that befell her, are incredibly deep, and Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tommorow almost feels like an episode posing a challenge to its viewers: what would you have done in her place?

This storyline also updates that of Khan and his augments, changing parts of Star Trek’s internal timeline. The Romulan super-spy seemed to imply that the actions of a variety of time-traveling factions may be to blame for Khan’s rise to power taking place decades later than it was supposed to – and that’s something we’ll have to digest or figure out later if it ever returns as a major plot point!

Young Khan.

For now, suffice to say that I’m not a canon “purist,” and I like the idea of Star Trek refreshing and updating itself. That being said, I don’t necessarily feel that the specific timing of Khan’s rise to power is some kind of gaping plot hole that needs to be plugged, even as Star Trek continues to tell modern-day time-travel stories that, in theory, contradict or overwrite parts of the franchise’s prior history. Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow could have proceeded just fine without this somewhat ambiguous line.

This was, perhaps, Strange New Worlds throwing a bone to long-term fans: people like you and I who remember Spock’s line in Space Seed confirming that Khan’s ship left Earth in the late 1990s. Is that a discrepancy? Sure, of course it is. But does it matter? Should all future Star Trek projects avoid modern-day time-travel because the franchise’s fictional history tells us that the late 20th and early 21st Centuries are radically different from how they actually turned out to be? Personally I don’t think so – though canon purists may disagree!

The crew of the Enterprise will meet Khan again…

At first, I was concerned that I wouldn’t be sold on Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow’s Kirk-La’an relationship. But as the story progressed, this turned out to be one of the episode’s strongest elements. The slow buildup to their shared kiss stood in contrast to other story beats that felt rushed or blitzed through too quickly, and by the time Kirk was dying in La’an’s arms, the love story that the episode had constructed truly hit home and formed a much stronger emotional core to the story than I’d been expecting.

Paul Wesley has earned my respect for not only taking on the role of Captain Kirk – a role that is fraught with criticism and that is watched hawkishly by fans – but for putting his own spin on it. Wesley’s Kirk isn’t an attempt to mimic William Shatner’s portrayal – nor Chris Pine’s, come to that. Paul Wesley has made the role his own, showing off his own range, his own emotions, and his own comedic timing. It’s not a carbon copy – any more than Ethan Peck’s Spock is a carbon copy of Leonard Nimoy’s. But I’m impressed with what he’s done with the character – and this alternate version in particular gave the actor a fair amount of leeway.

Paul Wesley as Captain Kirk.

Does La’an’s contact with Pelia form a paradox? I guess we could argue that it does! If Pelia was inspired to become an engineer by La’an in the past, then investigating her possessions was the reason why La’an was alone in the corridor when she crossed over to the alternate timeline, then… wait, my head hurts.

Pelia’s role in the episode was fun, paradoxes aside. It was neat to see Kirk and La’an tracking her down in the past, and the resolution to this side of the story both gives a bit of background to Pelia that we didn’t have before while also being a lighter moment as it became clear that she wasn’t an engineer and would be of no help whatsoever in creating a tracking device. Again, the resolution to this point felt rather contrived and rushed, but the scenes between La’an, Kirk, and Pelia were more than strong enough to carry the story through.

Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow was interesting for the character of Pelia.

Although it was obvious that there would be no “happily ever after” for La’an and Kirk, the way in which the latter was killed was still pretty brutal by Star Trek standards. The episode did a reasonable job at setting up the idea that La’an and Kirk had hope that he might’ve been able to transport back to the prime timeline, but it still felt like a sure thing that that wouldn’t be able to happen, no matter how much they wanted to believe it.

As mentioned, though, the let-down on this side of the story was the rapid, blink-and-you’ll-miss-it turnaround in Kirk. The episode wanted to say something like this: after seeing Earth for the first time with his own eyes, learning of his brother’s survival, and hearing La’an’s tales of a United Federation of Planets and a peaceful, prosperous humanity, Kirk was willing to sacrifice his timeline in order to bring hers into being. Self-sacrifice is a well-established Kirk trait, so that tracks.

Kirk was killed.

But there just wasn’t enough time for this to play out effectively, and it makes the story substantially weaker than it could’ve been. In order to fit in everything else that Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow wanted – the visit to Pelia, the relationship buildup, the car chase, La’an’s run-in with Khan, etc. – this side of things took a back seat. And while other story points worked well, I’m having a hard time with this supposedly grizzled, battle-hardened version of Kirk being so willing to wipe everyone he’s ever known from existence.

This is something that could have been made more of, particularly in terms of a conflict between La’an and Kirk. Two characters from two alternate realities find themselves at the “fork in the road,” where one path leads to one timeline and the other path to a very different one. There was potential in the idea of them arguing over which way to go, because from Kirk’s perspective at least, don’t his people have as much of a right to exist as La’an’s? The episode just didn’t spend much time on what could have been a really interesting idea – and the result of that is that Kirk’s turnaround feels incredibly abrupt.

We could’ve spent longer on this idea.

The episode’s epilogue contained a truly heartbreaking scene. La’an was confronted with the reality that the prime timeline version of Kirk had no idea who she was, and no recollection of the time she’d shared with his alternate counterpart. All credit must go to Christina Chong for a deeply emotional and raw performance; I genuinely felt La’an’s emptiness, loneliness, and heartbreak as she broke down and cried.

The end of Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow feels bleak in more ways than one. La’an had to commit to her ancestor’s genocidal reign, but also lost the sole human connection that we’d ever seen her make. La’an has friendly relationships with her shipmates, but Kirk was something different – someone who seemed to understand her and who didn’t feel encumbered by the weight of her past. La’an caught a glimpse of what that could be like – but it was brutally ripped away from her.

La’an’s heartbreak was a sad end to the episode.

So a bit of a contradictory one this week! Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow is one of Star Trek’s best modern-day time-travel stories. It was fun and lighthearted in places, dense and heavy in others, and it connected back to The Original Series in clever and unexpected ways. But it was let down by trying to cram in one too many storylines, with the result being that several key moments and elements of characterisation were missing, lessening the impact as the story wore on.

I had a good time this week, all things considered. Pairing up Kirk with La’an was a risk, but because this version of Kirk came from an alternate reality, I think we can say it’s a risk that paid off. It was a great episode for La’an’s characterisation, bringing her face-to-face with the monster from her past, but also taking her on an emotional rollercoaster and showing off a side of her that we haven’t always gotten to see.

There’s only one question left to ask: will Captain Pike finally get a role to play next time?!

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Seasons 1-2 are available to stream now on Paramount Plus in countries and territories where the service is available. The Star Trek franchise – including Strange New Worlds – is the copyright of Paramount Global. This article contains the thoughts and opinions of one person only and is not intended to cause any offence.